What yogurt is and how milk turns into yogurt
Yogurt is milk that has been fermented by specific bacteria. Those bacteria feed on lactose, the natural sugar in milk, and produce lactic acid. As the acid builds up, the milk becomes more acidic, and the main milk protein (casein) starts to link together and form a soft gel. That gel is what you recognize as yogurt, and the lactic acid is what gives it its tang.
That is the whole process behind milk turning into yogurt: warm milk, live bacteria, time. Everything else in a recipe, such as heating the milk first, holding a steady temperature and chilling at the end, is there to help those bacteria work and to give you a better texture.
At home you only need two ingredients:
- Milk, usually whole cow’s milk
- A starter, which is a small amount of yogurt that already contains live cultures, or a freeze-dried culture
The bacteria that make yogurt
Standard yogurt is made with two bacteria that work as a team:
- Streptococcus thermophilus
- Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus (often shortened to Lactobacillus bulgaricus)
Both convert lactose into lactic acid, and the pair also contribute to yogurt’s flavor and texture. Many commercial yogurts add extra strains such as Lactobacillus acidophilus or Bifidobacterium species, but the two above are the classic yogurt starter.
Is yogurt cultured? Yes. Yogurt is a cultured dairy food, meaning it is made by adding live bacterial cultures to milk. One caveat for store-bought yogurt: some products are heat-treated after fermenting, which can leave them without live bacteria, so look for “live and active cultures” on the label if you plan to use one as a starter. For a wider look at the category, see what cultured milk is.
What you need
- A heavy pot with a lid
- A thermometer (an instant-read or clip-on candy thermometer works well)
- A whisk or spoon, and a small bowl
- Clean jars or containers with lids
- A way to keep the milk warm: see the incubation options below
- Milk and a starter
Whole or 2% milk gives the thickest, creamiest result, while skim works but tends to be thinner. For a closer comparison of milk types, see the best milk for making yogurt.
Step-by-step method
This makes about two quarts, using half a gallon of milk.
Heat the milk
Pour the milk into the pot and heat it gently, stirring now and then so the bottom doesn’t scorch, until it reaches about 180°F (82°C). Many recipes call for 180 to 200°F, and you should avoid letting it boil. Heating changes the whey proteins so they hold onto water better, which gives a thicker, more stable yogurt that is less likely to separate. If you want to know whether this step is optional, read do you have to heat milk to make yogurt.
Cool to incubation temperature
Let the milk cool to roughly 110°F (43°C). Many recipes accept anything from about 105 to 115°F. You can stir it now and then, or set the pot in a sink of cold water to speed it up. If the milk is too hot when you add the starter, you will kill the bacteria, so check with the thermometer rather than guessing.
Add the starter
Scoop about a cup of the warm milk into a small bowl, add your starter and whisk until smooth. Then stir that mixture back into the pot. Plain yogurt with live cultures is the easy route: a common guideline is roughly 2 tablespoons per quart, though some recipes use more. See how much yogurt culture to use for a gallon of milk if you are scaling up, and yogurt starter cultures for the pros and cons of store-bought, freeze-dried and heirloom starters.
Incubate
Cover the pot, or pour the milk into clean jars with lids, and keep it warm and still at around 100 to 110°F. Most batches take between 4 and 12 hours to set, and some people go longer for a tangier result. The longer it incubates, the thicker and more sour it generally becomes. If this is your first batch, start checking at about 4 to 6 hours. Avoid stirring or jostling it until it has set.
Chill
Once it has set to your liking, move it to the refrigerator for several hours. Chilling slows the bacteria and firms up the texture. If you see watery whey on top, you can pour it off or stir it back in.
Making creamy homemade yogurt
Creaminess comes from a few choices:
- Use whole milk. Fat contributes body and richness.
- Heat the milk to about 180°F and hold it there a little while if you want a thicker set. Some cooks hold it for 20 to 30 minutes, which also evaporates a bit of water.
- Cool slowly and incubate undisturbed. Moving the jar while it sets can break the gel.
- Whisk gently once it is chilled if the texture is uneven. Whisking can smooth it out.
- Strain it. For Greek-style yogurt, line a sieve with cheesecloth or a clean cloth and drain the yogurt in the fridge for a few hours or longer. The longer it drains, the thicker it becomes, and the whey that collects can go into smoothies, pancakes or baking. Straining takes out liquid, so you will end up with noticeably less yogurt than you started with.
- Add milk powder. A few tablespoons of dry milk powder per quart increases the milk solids and thickens the result. This is a popular fix for lower-fat milk.
Ways to keep milk warm without a yogurt maker
You do not need special equipment, but you need a steady, gentle warmth:
- An oven that is off, with just the light turned on (check with a thermometer first, since ovens vary)
- A heavy pot with a lid, wrapped in towels
- An insulated cooler with warm water or a hot water bottle
- An Instant Pot with a yogurt setting
- A food dehydrator set to the right temperature
- A rice cooker or slow cooker on a low or warm setting, which varies by model, so test with water and a thermometer first
- A dedicated yogurt maker
If the temperature dips a little below 110°F, the yogurt will usually still set, only more slowly.
Troubleshooting
- It didn’t set. The starter may have been old or lacked live cultures, the milk may have been too hot when you added it, or it may have been too cool during incubation. Give it more time first. If it still looks like milk after 12 hours or so, start over with a fresh starter.
- It’s thin or runny. Use whole milk, heat the milk to about 180°F, add milk powder or strain it.
- It’s grainy or lumpy. The milk may have been too hot when the starter went in, or the yogurt may have been stirred while setting. Whisking after chilling can help.
- It’s very sour. It likely incubated too long or too warm. Shorten the time next time.
- Watery liquid on top. This is whey. It is normal. Stir it in or drain it.
- It smells off or shows mold, pink or orange discoloration. Discard it and start again with clean equipment.
For a longer list, see the common mistake when making yogurt.
Storing yogurt and keeping a starter going
Homemade yogurt generally keeps in the refrigerator for about one to two weeks, depending on how clean your equipment was and how cold your fridge runs. Store it in covered, clean containers.
You can save about half a cup, or a few tablespoons, of each batch to start the next one. Commercial yogurt cultures can weaken after several generations, so if the flavor changes or the batch sets slowly, go back to a fresh store-bought or freeze-dried starter. More on this in yogurt starter cultures.
Where to go next
- Wondering about the cost? See homemade vs store-bought yogurt.
- Using long-life milk? Read whether you can make yogurt with ultra-pasteurized milk.
- Have raw milk? Read how to make yogurt with raw milk first, because it carries food-safety considerations.