The three kinds of yogurt starter
Every batch of yogurt needs live bacteria to get it started. At home you can get them from three places:
| Starter | What it is | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Store-bought yogurt | Plain yogurt with live, active cultures | Beginners and casual batches |
| Freeze-dried starter | A packet of dried cultures, sold online and in some stores | Consistent results; non-dairy milks |
| Heirloom culture | A culture that has been passed along and re-cultured over many batches | Long-term, repeated batches; special styles like viili |
All three work. The right choice depends on how often you make yogurt, how much you care about a specific flavor, and whether you want to keep one culture going indefinitely.
Making yogurt from store-bought yogurt
This is the simplest way in and the one most recipes assume. Warm the milk, stir in a few spoonfuls of yogurt, keep it warm and wait. The full method is in our guide to making yogurt at home.
What to look for on the label
- Plain and unsweetened. Flavored or sweetened yogurts can interfere with the set.
- “Live and active cultures” in the ingredients or on the label. The live bacteria are what turn milk into yogurt. Some yogurts are heat-treated after fermenting, which can kill the bacteria, so check.
- A short ingredient list. Milk and cultures is ideal.
How many strains are listed doesn’t affect whether it will set: any live yogurt culture can make yogurt. Some cooks like to choose a yogurt that lists more strains, such as L. bulgaricus, S. thermophilus, L. acidophilus, Bifidus and L. casei, for the variety, but that is a preference rather than a requirement. Different brands can also give slightly different flavors.
Can you use Greek yogurt as a starter?
Yes, provided it is plain and lists live cultures. Greek yogurt has been strained, so it is thicker, but the bacteria are still there. Many home cooks use it. Stir it into a little warm milk first so it blends smoothly. For how much to use, see how much yogurt culture for a gallon of milk.
How long does a store-bought starter last?
If you save a little of each batch to start the next, you can keep going for a while, but commercial cultures tend to weaken over successive generations. Some fermenters report they only last a handful of batches before the yogurt sets slowly, turns thin or tastes off. There is no exact number that applies to everyone, since it depends on the brand, your hygiene and your temperatures.
Signs it is time to start over with a fresh store-bought or freeze-dried culture:
- The yogurt takes noticeably longer to set
- It is thinner than it used to be
- The flavor has changed in an unpleasant way
If a batch tastes and smells fine, it should be safe to eat even when the culture is weakening. If it smells off or shows mold, throw it out.
Freeze-dried starter cultures
Freeze-dried starters come as a packet or jar of dried bacteria. Reasons people choose them:
- Consistency. You know roughly what strains you are getting.
- A clean restart. They are handy when a saved culture has weakened.
- Specialty strains. Some packets are formulated for particular textures or flavors.
- Non-dairy milks. Plant-based milks generally need a specific starter, and the culture usually cannot be carried forward from one batch to the next in the same way, so you need fresh starter each time.
Always follow the packet. Some freeze-dried starters can be re-cultured several times and some are meant for a single batch. Some packets are sized for a particular volume of milk, while some makers say the same packet amount works for larger batches. Check the instructions for your brand before scaling up.
Heirloom yogurt cultures
An heirloom culture is a yogurt culture that has been maintained by re-culturing it, batch after batch, often over many years. Fans like heirlooms because they tend to be stable and keep their character from batch to batch. Some come from families or communities, and others are sold online by culture suppliers.
Thermophilic vs mesophilic
Heirloom cultures fall into two families:
- Thermophilic cultures want warmth, usually around 100 to 115°F, so you incubate them the way you would a standard yogurt, in an oven with the light on, a yogurt maker or a warm cooler. Bulgarian-style and Greek-style yogurts are examples.
- Mesophilic cultures ferment at room temperature, roughly 70 to 77°F, so you can set them on the counter without heating the milk or buying equipment. Viili, filmjolk and matsoni are common examples and tend to be milder, with a different texture from classic yogurt.
If you don’t want to fiddle with incubation temperatures, a mesophilic culture is worth a look. If you want the classic spoonable tang, choose a thermophilic one.
Why Bulgarian yogurt gets mentioned so often
Lactobacillus bulgaricus gets its name from Bulgaria, and Bulgarian yogurt is traditionally an unstrained, tangy yogurt. When a seller advertises a “Bulgarian” starter, they are usually pointing to that classic profile. Beyond that, it is just a style of yogurt, not a guarantee of any particular health benefit.
Which starter should you choose?
- Trying yogurt for the first time: use plain store-bought yogurt with live cultures.
- Making yogurt every week and want reliability: a freeze-dried or heirloom starter, kept going with careful habits, may serve you better.
- Want to skip incubation equipment: consider a mesophilic heirloom.
- Making non-dairy yogurt: use a starter formulated for it and expect to buy fresh starter regularly.
- Culture has gone weak: restart with a fresh packet or a fresh tub of plain yogurt.
Keeping a starter healthy from batch to batch
A few habits help any re-cultured starter last longer:
- Keep the seed in its own jar. Reserve some of the yogurt for the next batch in a separate container so nobody eats it by mistake.
- Take the seed jar out of the warm spot as soon as it sets. If you let other jars ferment longer for tang, remove the seed jar early so the bacteria still have lactose left to eat while it waits in the fridge.
- Don’t wait too long between batches. About a week is a comfortable interval for many cooks. Refrigeration slows the bacteria but doesn’t stop them. If you wait longer, you can feed the seed jar with some clean, scalded and cooled milk.
- Keep lids on while it ferments. This helps keep out yeasts and unwanted bacteria.
- Stir cream-top yogurt before saving a seed. If you use non-homogenized milk, the bacteria can rise with the cream, so stir before you take your seed.
- Use clean tools. Wash jars and utensils well.
Other traditional starters
People have started yogurt in many ways. In parts of South India, a few chili stems or a little tamarind has been used to start curd. A dried cloth soaked in yogurt has been used to carry cultures between households. Results from these methods vary, and the flavor and texture often differ from standard yogurt, so treat them as fun experiments rather than a reliable first method.