Yogurt Basics

What is the common mistake when making yogurt?

The most common yogurt-making mistake is getting the temperature wrong. Learn this and other frequent errors, why they ruin a batch, and how to fix each one.

On this page
  1. The most common mistake: getting the temperature wrong
  2. Other common mistakes
  3. Quick checklist
  4. Related guides

The most common mistake: getting the temperature wrong

The mistake that spoils the most batches is mishandling temperature, usually in one of two ways:

  1. Adding the starter when the milk is too hot. The bacteria in yogurt are alive, and milk that is too hot will kill them. Most recipes add the starter at about 105 to 115°F (about 40 to 46°C). One yogurt-maker manufacturer warns that temperatures above about 43°C (109°F) will kill the starter. If the batch never sets, this is a prime suspect.
  2. Not keeping the milk warm enough while it incubates. The bacteria work best around 100 to 110°F. If the milk cools too much, the yogurt sets slowly, ends up loose or doesn’t set at all. A small dip below 110°F is generally fine and just takes longer, but a cold kitchen with no insulation can stall things completely.

The fix is simple: use a thermometer instead of guessing, and give the jar a stable warm spot. See how to make yogurt at home for temperatures and incubation options.

Other common mistakes

Using a starter without live cultures

Starter yogurt has to contain live, active cultures. Some products are heat-treated after fermenting, which kills the bacteria, and flavored or sweetened yogurts may not work well. Check the label for “live and active cultures” and choose plain yogurt. See yogurt starter cultures.

Reusing a tired starter

If you re-culture from your own batches, a commercial culture can weaken after a number of generations. Signs include slow setting, a thin texture and changes in flavor. Restart with a fresh tub of plain yogurt or a freeze-dried culture.

Moving or stirring the jar while it sets

The gel that makes yogurt forms while the jar sits undisturbed. Jostling or stirring it before it has set can leave it runny or grainy. Leave it alone until it is set, and if you want a smooth texture, whisk gently after chilling.

Skipping the heating step and expecting thick yogurt

Heating milk to about 180°F before cooling and culturing changes the whey proteins and gives a thicker, more stable yogurt. If you skip it, the result may be thinner and wheyier, although it can still be tasty and can be strained. Whether you can skip it depends on your milk. See do you have to heat milk to make yogurt.

Using low-fat milk and expecting creamy

Skim and low-fat milk make thinner yogurt. Use whole milk, add some dry milk powder, or strain the finished yogurt to thicken it. See the best milk for making yogurt.

Incubating too long or too short

Too short, and the yogurt may be loose and mild. Too long, and it can get very sour, with more whey separating. Most batches take 4 to 12 hours. If you are new to it, start checking after about 4 to 6 hours and stop when it has the flavor and firmness you like.

Using too much or too little starter

A tiny pinch of weak starter can set slowly, and a huge amount rarely helps. Stick with the usual amounts. See how much yogurt culture for a gallon of milk.

Unclean equipment

Unwashed jars and utensils can introduce unwanted bacteria or yeasts that compete with your culture. Wash everything thoroughly, and keep lids on while it ferments. If a batch smells off, or has mold or pink or orange discoloration, throw it out.

Surprises from your milk

Some milks behave differently. Ultra-pasteurized milk can give mixed results, and raw milk raises safety questions. See making yogurt with ultra-pasteurized milk and making yogurt with raw milk.

Quick checklist

  • Heat the milk to about 180°F (optional for some pasteurized milks)
  • Cool to about 110°F before adding starter
  • Use plain yogurt with live cultures, or a fresh freeze-dried starter
  • Mix the starter smoothly into a little warm milk first
  • Keep it warm and undisturbed
  • Chill before eating
  • Use clean equipment

The complete guide to yogurt basics

How to Make Yogurt at Home: The Complete Beginner's Guide
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →