Yogurt Makers and Methods

How to Make Yogurt in a Slow Cooker, Step by Step

Make yogurt in a slow cooker with just milk and starter: heat on low, cool, add culture, wrap in towels and wait 8 to 12 hours. Includes tips and fixes.

On this page
  1. Why this method works
  2. What you need
  3. Step by step
  4. Check your slow cooker first
  5. Making it thicker (Greek-style)
  6. Troubleshooting
  7. Storage

A slow cooker makes a good yogurt incubator because it gives you a large, insulated, low-heat vessel that most kitchens already have. You do not need a dedicated machine for this (see do you really need a yogurt maker?), and the method makes a big batch in one go.

Why this method works

Yogurt bacteria are active at roughly 100°F to 115°F (about 38°C to 46°C). The slow cooker is used in two ways:

  1. On low, it gently heats the milk to around 180°F (82°C), which helps the milk proteins set into a thicker yogurt.
  2. With the heat off, its thick insulated crock holds the cooling milk warm, and a towel wrapped around it helps keep the temperature in the right range while the cultures work.

What you need

  • Milk: 1/2 gallon to 1 gallon of whole milk. Lower-fat milk gives a thinner result, and ultra-pasteurized milk may not set as firmly.
  • Starter: about 1/2 cup of plain yogurt with live and active cultures per half gallon, or a packet of starter following its instructions. Plain, unsweetened yogurt without added thickeners is the simplest choice.
  • A slow cooker with a lid, a thermometer, a whisk or spoon, and large towels or a blanket.
  • Optional: cheesecloth and a colander for Greek-style yogurt, and clean jars for storage.

Step by step

  1. Heat the milk. Pour the milk into the slow cooker, put the lid on and set it to low. Many recipes use about 2 1/2 hours, but cookers vary, so check with a thermometer. You are aiming for about 180°F.
  2. Turn it off and cool. Unplug the cooker and leave the lid on. Let the milk cool undisturbed for around 3 hours, until it reaches roughly 110°F to 115°F. Use a thermometer rather than the clock the first time.
  3. Temper the starter. Scoop a cup or two of the warm milk into a bowl, whisk in the starter until smooth, then pour it back and stir gently but thoroughly.
  4. Wrap and incubate. Put the lid back on and wrap the whole slow cooker in a couple of big towels or a blanket. Leave it, still unplugged, for 8 to 12 hours. Overnight works well. Avoid stirring or moving it.
  5. Chill. Transfer the yogurt to clean containers and refrigerate for several hours. It thickens as it cools.
  6. Save a starter. Set aside about 1/2 cup of this batch in a clean container for next time.

Check your slow cooker first

Slow cookers differ a lot. Some “low” settings reach 180°F in under two hours, while others take longer, and some run hot enough to scorch milk. On your first batch:

  • measure the milk temperature at the end of heating
  • measure again as it cools, and add the starter only when the milk is at or below about 115°F
  • if it is still warm enough to feel hot rather than comfortably warm, wait longer

Milk that is too hot can kill the starter, and milk that is too cool may not set. Once you know how long your slow cooker takes, you may not need to check every time.

Making it thicker (Greek-style)

For Greek-style yogurt, line a colander with cheesecloth, a clean cloth or coffee filters, set it over a bowl, and pour in the finished yogurt. Cover and refrigerate to drain, usually about 2 to 4 hours for a thick yogurt and longer for a very thick one. Keep the whey for baking, smoothies or soups. Our Instant Pot Greek yogurt guide has more on straining and how much yogurt to expect.

Troubleshooting

  • Runny yogurt: The milk may have been too hot or too cool when the starter went in, the starter may have been weak, or the batch may need more chill time. You can also strain it.
  • Grainy or lumpy texture: The milk may have overheated or the starter may not have been mixed in smoothly. Whisking and tempering the starter helps.
  • Very sour yogurt: It may have incubated too long, or the batch may have been warm. Try a shorter incubation next time.
  • Yogurt gets thinner over successive homemade batches: Starter strength can drop over generations. Begin again with fresh commercial yogurt or a fresh starter packet.
  • Anything that smells off, or shows pink or orange tints or fuzz, should be thrown out.

For more on timing, see how long it takes to make yogurt.

Storage

Keep yogurt covered in the fridge. Homemade yogurt is commonly kept for about one to two weeks and gets tangier over time. Freezing is possible, but the texture often turns grainy when thawed, so frozen yogurt is better used in smoothies or baking.

If your kitchen does not suit towel-wrapped incubation, an oven with the light on or a sous vide water bath are other ways to hold milk at the right temperature.

The complete guide to yogurt makers and methods

The Best Yogurt Makers for Home Use
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →