Short answer
Yes, in most cases you can make yogurt with ultra-pasteurized or UHT milk, and it can even let you skip the heating step. The catch is that results are less predictable than with standard pasteurized milk. Some people get a good, firm set, while others find the yogurt thin or watery. Brand, culture and method all play a part.
What “ultra-pasteurized” and UHT mean
Standard pasteurization heats milk to a lower temperature for a short time, for example about 72°C (161.6°F) for at least 15 seconds. Ultra-high-temperature (UHT) treatment heats milk to a much higher temperature, around 135°C (275°F), for about two seconds. This leaves the milk close to sterile.
A note on labels: “ultra-pasteurized” is often used for refrigerated milk that has been heated to ultra-high temperatures but is not necessarily packaged to be shelf-stable. “UHT” or “long-life” milk is typically packaged aseptically and can sit unopened at room temperature for months. Both have had very high heat treatment, and the same yogurt advice generally applies. Check the carton to see what you have.
Why results are mixed
- It’s nearly sterile. There are few competing bacteria in the milk, so your starter has a clear run. That is why a no-heat method can work.
- The proteins have already been heated. Heating milk before making yogurt is meant to change the whey proteins for a firmer set, and UHT milk has had that treatment already. In practice, some home cooks report a good set, and others report thinner yogurt than with regular pasteurized milk. Opinions in community forums are split, and some recipe writers advise against ultra-pasteurized milk when you can avoid it.
- Varying brands. Different processing and packaging can change the outcome.
If you have a choice, standard pasteurized whole milk is the safer bet, as covered in the best milk for making yogurt. But if ultra-pasteurized or UHT is what you have, it is worth a try.
Two ways to make yogurt with UHT milk
Cold-start (no heating)
Because the milk is already treated, you don’t need to heat it to sterilize it. Some recipes use it straight from the carton.
- Make sure your jar and tools are clean, since the milk itself is sterile and anything unclean you add can grow in it.
- Bring the milk to the starter’s working temperature, around 100 to 110°F (38 to 43°C), or at least take the chill off. Some recipes mix the starter into cool milk and let it warm up in the incubator.
- Whisk in your starter. Plain yogurt with live cultures or a freeze-dried culture both work. A few tablespoons of yogurt per quart is a common amount.
- Incubate at about 100°F (38°C). Times in recipes vary, from around 8 to 12 hours up to 12 to 24 hours.
- Chill in the fridge for several hours, ideally at least 6, before eating or straining. Don’t stir it while it’s warm, or it may not set cleanly.
Heat-and-cool with milk powder
For a thicker result, many cooks warm the milk and add dry milk powder.
- Whisk about 1/3 cup of dry milk powder into each liter of milk.
- Heat gently, stirring so the powder doesn’t stick to the bottom, until it is just short of boiling.
- Cool to below about 42°C (107°F). Temperatures above about 43°C risk killing the culture. It is fine if it cools further, as long as it isn’t too hot.
- Whisk in the starter, pour into a clean jar and incubate.
For a step-by-step basic method, see how to make yogurt at home.
Tips for a better set
- Add milk powder for extra protein and thickness.
- Strain it. If it turns out thin, draining the whey through cloth in the fridge gives you a thicker, Greek-style yogurt.
- Choose whole milk. Fat adds creaminess.
- Keep the temperature steady and the jar undisturbed. See the most common yogurt-making mistake.
- Use a lively starter. An old, tired culture struggles more in an unforgiving milk.
- Use a fresh carton. Once opened, UHT milk is no longer sterile and should be handled like any other milk.
When to choose a different milk
If you try UHT milk twice and the results are always thin or inconsistent, switch to standard pasteurized whole milk and see whether things improve. If you are wondering whether heating is needed in general, see do you have to heat milk to make yogurt.