Greek and Strained Yogurt

How to Make Thick Greek Yogurt at Home

Make thick Greek yogurt at home with milk, a spoonful of starter and a strainer. Covers temperatures, straining times, troubleshooting and storage.

On this page
  1. What makes Greek yogurt thick
  2. Ingredients and equipment
  3. Step-by-step method
  4. How long to strain for the thickness you want
  5. Tips for thicker yogurt
  6. Troubleshooting
  7. Storing homemade Greek yogurt and saving starter
  8. Common mistakes when making yogurt
  9. Eating and cooking with it
  10. Related guides

What makes Greek yogurt thick

Greek yogurt is ordinary yogurt that has been strained. After milk is cultured and sets, the liquid whey that separates is drained off. What remains is more concentrated: thicker, tangier, and higher in protein per spoonful than unstrained yogurt.

So what is Greek yogurt made from? Milk and live bacterial cultures, then straining. Commercial versions are mostly cow’s milk, though traditional Greek yogurt is often made with sheep’s or goat’s milk. Some store-bought “Greek-style” products use thickeners instead of straining. At home you only need milk, a starter and time. (For the labeling differences, see Greek yogurt vs Greek-style vs regular yogurt.)

Yes, Greek yogurt is thicker than regular yogurt, and the difference comes down to how much whey has been removed. That also means you control the thickness. Strain for a short time and you get a thick, spoonable yogurt. Strain for much longer and it turns into something closer to soft cheese.

Ingredients and equipment

Ingredients

  • 2 quarts (about 2 liters) of milk. Whole milk gives the creamiest, thickest result. 2% also works.
  • About 1/4 cup of plain yogurt with live active cultures, at room temperature, as a starter. A commercial plain yogurt is fine. Use a fresh container and check the label for live cultures.

Equipment

  • A heavy-bottomed pot
  • A thermometer (a digital probe thermometer is easiest)
  • A clean jar, bowl or insulated container for incubating
  • A fine-mesh strainer or colander, a bowl to catch the whey, and a straining cloth. If you don’t have cheesecloth, see how to strain Greek yogurt without cheesecloth.

Step-by-step method

1. Heat the milk

Warm the milk over medium-low heat, stirring now and then so it does not scorch, until it reaches about 180°F (82°C). Don’t let it boil hard. Heating to this point changes the milk proteins so they set into a firmer gel. Some cooks hold the milk near this temperature for 10 to 30 minutes for an even thicker set.

2. Cool it to about 110°F

Let the milk cool to roughly 110°F (43°C). A sink of cold water or an ice bath speeds this up. This step matters: if the milk is too hot when the starter goes in, the cultures can be killed. If it is too cool, the yogurt sets slowly or not at all.

3. Add the starter

Whisk a ladle of the warm milk into the starter yogurt until smooth, then stir that mixture back into the pot. Mixing it separately first avoids lumps of cold yogurt.

4. Incubate

Pour the milk into your clean container, cover it, and keep it warm and undisturbed. Good options are an oven that is switched off with only the light on, a yogurt maker, or a container wrapped in a towel. Expect anywhere from about 4 to 12 hours. Shorter times give a milder yogurt. Longer times give a tangier one.

To check whether it has set, tilt the container gently. The yogurt should move as one mass and not slosh like milk. Try not to stir or jostle it while it is setting.

5. Chill, then strain

Refrigerate the set yogurt for a few hours, which firms it up and makes it easier to handle. Then line a strainer with cloth, set it over a bowl, spoon the yogurt in, and put the whole thing in the refrigerator to drain. The liquid collecting in the bowl is whey. Don’t pour it away, because it has plenty of uses (see what to do with leftover whey).

How long to strain for the thickness you want

Straining times vary with the milk, the fridge and the yogurt itself, so treat these as rough guides and check as you go:

Straining time Typical result
About 1-2 hours Thick, spoonable yogurt, similar to many “Greek-style” tubs
About 3-6 hours Dense Greek yogurt that holds its shape
Overnight (8-24 hours) Very thick, almost cream-cheese-like. Suited to dips and spreads

Because whey is lost, you end up with noticeably less than you started with. For a worked estimate, see how much Greek yogurt a gallon of milk makes.

Tips for thicker yogurt

  • Use whole milk. More milk fat and solids mean a thicker, creamier result. For something richer still, try the triple cream yogurt recipe.
  • Heat the milk properly. Reaching about 180°F matters more than most people expect.
  • Keep it warm and still while it sets. Moving the container disrupts the gel.
  • Strain a bit longer. It is the most reliable way to thicken a batch that set softly.
  • Stir a little milk powder into the milk before heating, if you like. This adds milk solids, though it changes the flavor slightly.

Troubleshooting

  • Runny and not set: The milk may have been too hot or too cool when the starter went in, the starter may have been old or weak, or the spot was too cool. If it hasn’t set after 12 hours or so, it’s usually easier to start a new batch than keep waiting.
  • Grainy or lumpy: This usually means the milk was too hot when the starter was added, or the yogurt was stirred or moved while setting. Whisking or blending a grainy batch can smooth it out.
  • Too sour: Incubation ran too long. Shorten the time next batch, and chill the yogurt as soon as it has set.
  • Too thin after straining: Return it to the strainer for a while longer.
  • Off smell, pink or orange streaks, or mold: Throw it out.

Storing homemade Greek yogurt and saving starter

Keep the finished yogurt in a covered container in the refrigerator. It is generally best within about a week. Save a few spoonfuls of your own yogurt to start the next batch. Most home cooks find the starter works for a number of batches, but if the yogurt starts setting more slowly or tastes off, begin again with a fresh store-bought starter.

Common mistakes when making yogurt

  • Adding the starter when the milk is still too hot
  • Using a starter without live cultures, or one that is old
  • Skipping the thermometer and guessing at temperatures
  • Moving or stirring the yogurt during incubation
  • Incubating far too long, which gives sour, watery yogurt
  • Using dirty containers, which can cause off flavors

Eating and cooking with it

You can certainly eat Greek yogurt on its own. Plain, it is tangy, so many people add honey, fruit or nuts. It also works as a swap in recipes. See whether Greek yogurt can replace whole milk yogurt.

Is it okay to heat Greek yogurt? Gentle warming is usually fine, but high heat can make yogurt split and turn grainy, particularly low-fat versions. When cooking, stir it in at the end, off the heat or on very low heat, and prefer full-fat yogurt.

As for portion size, 100 g of Greek yogurt is a little under half a cup, or roughly six to seven tablespoons.

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →