Quick picks by need
Models, prices and availability change often, so treat the prices below as rough ranges and check the current listing before buying.
- Most people starting out: the Euro Cuisine YMX650, a digital machine with seven 6-oz glass jars and a timer with automatic shut-off, usually around $60.
- Lowest cost: the simpler Euro Cuisine YM80, which has seven jars and basic controls, often listed around $35 to $40.
- Long ferments and adjustable temperature: the Luvele Pure Plus (water-bath heating, roughly $125) or the Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker (adjustable temperature and a long timer, roughly $60 to $90).
- Big family batches: a one- or two-quart machine such as the Yogourmet, or a multi-cooker you may already own.
- Thicker Greek-style yogurt: a strainer such as the Euro Cuisine GY50 or a similar mesh basket. This thickens finished yogurt but does not ferment it.
What a yogurt maker actually does
A yogurt maker does one job: it holds milk and starter culture at a steady, gentle warmth for several hours. Yogurt bacteria are active at roughly 100°F to 115°F (about 38°C to 46°C), and most of the effort in homemade yogurt is keeping milk in that range without babysitting it.
Most machines do not heat the milk to the starting point for you. You still typically warm the milk to about 180°F (82°C), let it cool to around 110°F (43°C), and stir in a spoonful of live-culture yogurt, then the machine takes over. If you want a feel for the whole process, see our walkthrough on how long yogurt takes to make in a yogurt maker.
How to choose
Jars or one big container. Individual jars (usually six or seven) make portioning, flavoring and grab-and-go easy. A single large container suits people who eat yogurt daily, strain it for Greek-style yogurt, or use it in cooking. Some machines support both formats.
Timer and automatic shut-off. A timer lets you start the batch in the evening and forget it. A short maximum timer (some basic models stop around 15 hours) is fine for ordinary overnight yogurt but can rule out long ferments.
Temperature control. Many inexpensive machines run at a single fixed temperature. That is fine for standard yogurt. If you want to ferment at a specific temperature, such as for L. reuteri yogurt, look for an adjustable range and a long timer.
Build and cleaning. Glass jars and dishwasher-safe parts are convenient. Check whether lids are included, how the jars sit in the base, and whether the heating base can be wiped clean without crevices where milk collects.
Dairy-free milks. Machines are not limited to dairy, but plant milks behave differently. See our notes on almond milk in a Dash yogurt maker.
Euro Cuisine YMX650
This is the model most often named as a top pick for beginners. It typically comes with seven 6-oz glass jars (42 oz in total), date-dial lids, a digital timer that can run up to about 15 hours, and automatic shut-off. It is compact, and the separate jars let you make different flavors in one batch.
Things to know: some owners report that it runs slightly warm, so it is worth checking the first batch early rather than assuming the maximum time. See our Euro Cuisine yogurt maker review for more detail.
Euro Cuisine YM80
A simpler, cheaper electric maker in the same jar format: seven 6-oz glass jars and basic one-switch operation. It is a reasonable low-cost way to try a machine, though it offers fewer conveniences than the digital model. Batches generally take around 6 to 10 hours.
Luvele Pure Plus
Luvele machines use a water-bath design, in which the container sits in warmed water for more even heat, and offer adjustable temperature settings and a long timer. The Pure Plus is commonly described as having a 2.1-quart (2 L) glass container and a 36-hour timer, at roughly $125. It is a popular option for people who want long, low-temperature ferments, but it costs about twice as much as a basic jar machine.
Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker
This machine is often recommended for flexibility: adjustable temperature (listed from about 68°F to 131°F), a timer that can run up to 48 hours, and options with two 1-quart containers or a set of 6-oz glass jars. Owner opinions are mixed. Some praise the controls, while others mention plastic build quality and temperature swings, so it is sensible to verify the temperature with a thermometer.
Large-batch and older models
Two names appear repeatedly in older roundups:
- Yogourmet Electric Yogurt Maker: a water-bath style machine with a large container, often described as holding up to two quarts, usually bundled with a thermometer and a strainer.
- Cuisinart CYM-100: a one-and-a-half-liter machine with a 50-oz container and automatic cooling after fermentation.
These may be harder to find or may have been replaced by newer versions, so confirm current availability and specifications.
Dash
Dash’s bulk-style yogurt maker is a small, low-cost option with a capacity of about one quart and a modest footprint. It is a sensible choice for one or two people who want a single container rather than jars. We cover dairy and plant-milk results in our Dash yogurt maker review.
Greek yogurt strainers
Greek yogurt is regular yogurt with more of the liquid whey drained off. A strainer such as the Euro Cuisine GY50 or a fine stainless-steel mesh basket does that job in the fridge. It is not a heater or incubator, so you still need to ferment the yogurt first, or you can strain store-bought yogurt. A cheesecloth-lined colander does the same thing for less money.
If you already own another appliance
Many people do not need a dedicated machine. An Instant Pot with a yogurt setting, a slow cooker, an immersion circulator or even an oven with the light on can all hold yogurt at a workable temperature. Larger batches are often easier in these than in a jar machine. See:
- How to make yogurt and Greek yogurt in an Instant Pot
- How to make yogurt in a slow cooker
- Sous vide yogurt with an immersion circulator
- Yogurt in the oven with just the light on
Our page on whether you really need a yogurt maker walks through that decision.
Common mistakes
- Adding starter to milk that is too hot. Heat damages the cultures. Let the milk cool to roughly 110°F before stirring in the starter.
- Using too much starter. More is not better. A couple of tablespoons per quart is typical, and too much can lead to thinner, more sour yogurt.
- Using ultra-pasteurized milk and expecting a thick set. It may work but often sets more softly than regular pasteurized milk.
- Disturbing the jars during incubation. Jostling can cause a loose, watery set.
- Incubating much longer than needed. Longer times make yogurt tangier and can lead to more whey separating.
- Not checking your machine’s real temperature. Cheap machines can run warm or cool. Test with a thermometer once.
FAQ
Is a yogurt maker worth buying? If you make yogurt often and like the convenience of a set-and-forget machine, many people find it is. If you make it occasionally, a pot, a thermometer and a warm spot may be enough.
Which yogurt is best for people with diabetes? Plain, unsweetened yogurt contains no added sugar, which is why it is often suggested. Individual needs vary, so check with a doctor or registered dietitian.
Can I make Greek yogurt in a yogurt maker? Yes, by straining the finished yogurt through cheesecloth or a fine mesh to remove whey.
What if my yogurt is runny? Check the milk, starter amount and temperature, chill it fully before judging, and try straining it. Whole milk generally sets thicker than skim.