Can you make yogurt from probiotic capsules?
Sometimes, yes. You can open a probiotic capsule (or crush a tablet), stir the contents into warm milk, and keep it warm for many hours. Whether you get a set, spoonable yogurt depends on the strains inside the capsule, the milk, the temperature and how long you ferment.
Capsules are not formulated as yogurt starters. Many contain Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium strains chosen to survive in the gut, and not all of them ferment milk quickly or set it firmly. Some blends include Streptococcus thermophilus, a standard yogurt bacterium, which tends to help. Results vary by product, and forum reports on capsule yogurt are mixed.
The best-known use of this method is the long, low-temperature L. reuteri yogurt popularized by Dr. William Davis, which starts from crushed tablets (BioGaia Gastrus is the one most often named) or a dedicated starter sachet. This page covers the general method; the spokes linked below cover specific strains.
Choosing a capsule or starter
- Check the strain list. Strain-level names (for example L. reuteri, L. gasseri) matter more than the billion-CFU figure on the label.
- Look at the other ingredients. Fillers and flavorings can affect fermentation. Tablets, such as those used in L. reuteri recipes, are often flavored, though recipe authors report the flavor does not carry into the finished yogurt.
- Enteric or delayed-release coatings. Some brands advise against opening these capsules when taking them as a supplement. Opening them to inoculate milk is common practice, but results can differ.
- Dedicated starter sachets. If you want predictable results, a starter made for yogurt (including L. reuteri sachets and SCD-legal cultures) is usually more reliable than a supplement.
What you need
- A clean glass or ceramic jar or bowl that holds at least a quart (about 1 litre)
- 1 quart (1 litre) of milk or half-and-half
- A prebiotic such as inulin (2 tablespoons per quart is the amount most recipes use)
- Capsules or tablets as the starter, or 2 tablespoons of a previous batch
- A way to hold a steady temperature: a yogurt maker with adjustable temperature, a sous vide cooker, or an Instant Pot with a manual setting
- A food thermometer
Basic probiotic yogurt recipe with inulin
This is the common long-ferment method used for L. reuteri. If your capsules contain other strains, follow the product’s guidance on temperature and time where it gives any.
- Wash and rinse your jar and utensils well. Some makers also scald them with boiling water.
- If your milk is ultra-pasteurized (UHT), you can skip heating. If it is ordinary pasteurized milk, heat it to about 180°F (82°C), hold it for 20 to 30 minutes, then let it cool below about 107°F (42°C).
- In a small bowl, mix the inulin and the crushed tablets or capsule contents with a few tablespoons of milk to form a slurry. This stops the inulin forming lumps.
- Stir the slurry into the rest of the milk and pour it into the jar. Cover loosely.
- Ferment at about 97–100°F (36–38°C) for up to 36 hours without stirring.
- Refrigerate for at least 6 hours before eating. Keep the lid loose until the jar is cold, because fermentation can produce gas.
For fuller detail on the main ingredients, see our pages on inulin and other prebiotics, using half-and-half or cream and using whole milk.
Temperature, timing and equipment
Long-ferment L. reuteri yogurt is made at a lower temperature than conventional yogurt. Recipe authors generally give 97–100°F (36–38°C) and warn that heat above about 109–110°F (43°C) can damage the bacteria. Our guide to the right temperature for L. reuteri yogurt explains how to check your equipment.
Which yogurt maker is best? Brand matters less than control. Any device that holds a stable temperature in the right range will work, and makers commonly mentioned include Luvele, Severin and Rommelsbacher. Many standard yogurt makers and Instant Pots are set for conventional yogurt cultures and run hotter than the display suggests, so test with a thermometer and water before you commit a batch.
How long can you ferment yogurt? Conventional yogurt is often done in a few hours. L. reuteri recipes call for 24 to 36 hours, and SCD yogurt is made for 24 hours. Fermenting much longer than a recipe says is not generally recommended; the milk can become very sour, and spoilage risk rises if conditions are not clean and the temperature is off.
The most common mistakes
- Overheating the cultures. The most-cited problem is a yogurt maker or Instant Pot running too hot and killing the bacteria. If nothing has thickened after 12 to 16 hours, check the temperature first.
- Adding the starter to milk that is still too hot. Let heated milk cool before adding it.
- Skipping the prebiotic or using low-fat milk. Both tend to give a thinner result in long-ferment recipes.
- Not cleaning equipment. A long, warm ferment gives unwanted microbes more time to grow.
- Stirring or moving the jar during fermentation.
- Judging the first batch too harshly. A first batch that is thin or separated is common and does not necessarily mean failure. Use a couple of tablespoons of it for the next batch.
Reculturing your batches
Once you have a good batch, you can use about 2 tablespoons of it (curds, whey or a mix) to start the next one, which saves buying more capsules. How long to keep reculturing is debated. Dr. Davis’s followers commonly cite around 20 rounds, while Luvele suggests a fresh start after 4 to 5. If taste, smell or texture changes noticeably, start again from fresh capsules or a new starter.
Questions about capsules, supplements and medication
Can you open probiotic capsules and mix with food? Many people do, and it is the basis of capsule yogurt. Mix with cool or lukewarm food, not hot, since heat can kill the bacteria.
Is it okay to take probiotics with yogurt? For most healthy people, eating yogurt and taking a probiotic supplement are not known to conflict. If you have a medical condition or take medication, ask your pharmacist or doctor.
Can you take probiotics and pantoprazole at the same time? We cannot give medical advice on this. Ask your pharmacist or doctor about your own medicines.
If you are immunocompromised, pregnant, or giving probiotics to a child, speak to a clinician first. See also our notes on side effects of L. reuteri yogurt.
Where to go next
- Dr. William Davis’s L. gasseri yogurt recipe and what L. gasseri yogurt does
- L. reuteri coconut milk yogurt for a dairy-free version
- SCD 24-hour yogurt if you follow the Specific Carbohydrate Diet