Yogurt Basics

The Best Milk for Making Yogurt: Whole, Powdered and Goat Milk Compared

Which milk makes the best homemade yogurt? Compare whole, low-fat, UHT, goat, sheep, powdered and plant milks, with tips for thick, creamy results.

On this page
  1. The short answer: pasteurized whole cow’s milk
  2. How fat content changes the yogurt
  3. Pasteurization and homogenization
  4. Goat milk yogurt (and Greek-style goat yogurt)
  5. Sheep milk
  6. Powdered milk yogurt
  7. Lactose-free and plant-based milks
  8. Quick comparison
  9. Related guides

The short answer: pasteurized whole cow’s milk

For most home cooks, standard pasteurized whole milk is the most reliable choice. It sets firmly, tastes rich, and is easy to find. Fat adds body and creaminess, and whole milk’s roughly 3.25% fat content gives you a thick, smooth result without extra steps.

Other milks can work well, but each has quirks. Here is how they compare.

How fat content changes the yogurt

  • Whole milk: the thickest, creamiest result.
  • 2% milk: also works well and is a common choice for a lighter yogurt.
  • 1% and skim: these make thinner, more watery yogurt. They set, but you may want to compensate by adding a few tablespoons of dry milk powder per quart or by straining the finished yogurt.

If you want Greek-style yogurt, whole milk strained in the fridge is hard to beat. For a full method, see how to make yogurt at home.

Pasteurization and homogenization

  • Standard pasteurized milk is the most dependable base.
  • Ultra-pasteurized and UHT milk can work, but reports are mixed. Some people get a good set and others get thin yogurt. We cover this in detail in making yogurt with ultra-pasteurized milk.
  • Homogenized milk has the fat evenly distributed. Non-homogenized, cream-on-top milk will form a cream layer on top of the finished yogurt. Some people love that, and you can stir it back in if you prefer a uniform texture.
  • Raw milk needs extra care. See how to make yogurt with raw milk before using it.

Goat milk yogurt (and Greek-style goat yogurt)

Goat milk makes good yogurt with a distinct, slightly tangy flavor. Differences to expect:

  • A looser set. Goat milk generally has fewer milk solids than cow’s milk, so plain goat yogurt is often thinner.
  • Easy fixes. Strain it to make Greek-style goat yogurt, add milk powder, or use a little unflavored gelatin. One homesteading recipe blooms about 2 teaspoons of gelatin per 8 cups of milk, stirring it in when the heated milk has cooled somewhat.
  • Fresh milk matters. Use fresh, pasteurized goat milk without additives where possible.

For Greek-style goat yogurt, make your batch as usual, chill it, then drain it through cheesecloth or a fine sieve in the fridge until it is as thick as you like. The time varies, from a few hours to overnight.

Is goat yogurt healthier?

It is often said to be easier to digest, and some people who find cow’s milk uncomfortable do well with it. But goat milk still contains lactose and milk proteins, and it isn’t suitable for everyone with a cow’s milk allergy, since the proteins can be similar. If you have a medical concern, talk to a doctor or dietitian rather than relying on general claims.

Sheep milk

Sheep milk is richer than cow or goat milk, with higher fat and milk solids. It makes a naturally thicker yogurt that many people find mild and creamy. It can be harder to find and more expensive.

Powdered milk yogurt

Powdered milk is a handy pantry option, especially if fresh milk is hard to get or you want to stretch your budget.

Basic method

  1. Mix the milk powder with water according to the package directions for reconstituting, whisking until it is smooth and lump-free. Using a bit more powder than the package suggests gives a thicker yogurt.
  2. Heat it gently to about 180°F (82°C), stirring so it doesn’t stick or scorch, and skim off any film.
  3. Cool it to about 110°F (43°C).
  4. Whisk in your starter, which you have first mixed with a little of the warm milk.
  5. Incubate somewhere warm for about 8 to 12 hours until it sets.
  6. Chill for a few hours. Strain if you want it thicker.

Powdered-milk yogurt can taste slightly different from fresh-milk yogurt, so you may want to experiment with brands and ratios.

Using milk powder to boost regular milk

Dry milk powder also works as a booster. Adding a few tablespoons per quart, or around a third of a cup per liter in one UHT recipe, increases the proteins and gives a thicker yogurt. A Greek-style recipe from another source uses roughly 50 grams of powder to about 950 ml of whole milk.

Lactose-free and plant-based milks

  • Lactose-free milk is still dairy and generally works for yogurt.
  • Plant-based milks (soy, coconut, oat, nut) are different. They don’t contain the same milk proteins and sugar, so they often need a starter made for non-dairy milks, may need a thickener such as pectin or gelatin, and often don’t set firmly until chilled. Cultures for Health notes the culture generally can’t be re-cultured the way a dairy culture can, so plan to use fresh starter each time. Commercial almond milk in particular tends to give poor results, and additives and preservatives in store-bought plant milks can interfere with culturing.

Quick comparison

Milk Result Notes
Whole cow’s milk Thick and creamy The easy default
2% cow’s milk Slightly thinner Add milk powder or strain
Skim Thin Needs help from powder or straining
UHT / ultra-pasteurized Varies See our UHT guide
Goat milk Looser set, tangy Strain or add gelatin
Sheep milk Very thick and rich Harder to source
Powdered milk Good with enough powder Handy pantry option
Plant milks Needs special starter Often needs thickener

The complete guide to yogurt basics

How to Make Yogurt at Home: The Complete Beginner's Guide
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →