Yogurt Basics

How to Make Yogurt with Raw Milk: Safety, Temperatures and Texture

Making yogurt with raw milk: the safety risks, how to pasteurize at home first, the heat-and-cool method, and why raw milk yogurt often turns out thin.

On this page
  1. Read this first: raw milk and risk
  2. Three approaches
  3. Method 1: pasteurize at home, then make yogurt
  4. Method 2: heat to 180°F for a thicker set
  5. Method 3: warming without pasteurizing
  6. Texture: why raw milk yogurt can be thin
  7. Starter and incubation
  8. Handling and storage
  9. Goat and sheep raw milk
  10. Related guides

Read this first: raw milk and risk

Raw milk is milk that hasn’t been pasteurized. It can carry disease-causing bacteria, including Salmonella, E. coli and Listeria, even when it comes from a healthy-looking animal and a clean farm. Health agencies such as the US CDC and FDA recommend against drinking raw milk, and the risk is higher for young children, pregnant people, older adults and anyone with a weakened immune system. Laws on selling and buying raw milk vary by country and region, so check what applies where you live.

It is also a mistake to assume that turning raw milk into yogurt makes it safe. Yogurt’s acidity and the competing bacteria in it may reduce some risks, but that is not a reliable safeguard, so don’t rely on fermentation alone. If you decide to use raw milk, the safest option is to heat it first.

This article describes your options, with the trade-offs. It is general information, not medical advice.

Three approaches

Approach Safety Texture
1. Pasteurize at home, then culture Best of the three Good
2. Heat to about 180°F, cool, culture Strong heat treatment Thicker, firmer
3. Gentle warming only (a “raw” yogurt) Does not reduce pathogen risk meaningfully Thin, runny

Method 1: pasteurize at home, then make yogurt

Home pasteurization means holding milk at a set temperature for a set time. Two widely used standards are:

  • 145°F (63°C) held for 30 minutes, known as batch or vat pasteurization
  • 161°F (72°C) held for 15 seconds, known as high-temperature short-time pasteurization

At home, the batch method is easier to manage. Use an accurate thermometer, stir the milk often so the temperature is even through the pot, and keep the heat low enough that it doesn’t scorch. Because home setups can have hot and cold spots, many people aim slightly above 145°F and then hold. Once the time is up, cool the milk to about 110°F (43°C), and carry on with an ordinary yogurt recipe, as in how to make yogurt at home.

Method 2: heat to 180°F for a thicker set

Most standard recipes heat milk to about 180°F (82°C), which is hotter than pasteurization, then cool it to 110°F. Heating raw milk this way:

  • Reduces the risk from harmful bacteria more than gentle warming does
  • Makes yogurt that is thicker and more stable, because the whey proteins are changed by the heat

This is a reasonable choice if you want the best texture and a strong safety margin. Heat slowly, stir to avoid scorching, and don’t let the milk boil over. For more on why this step matters, see do you have to heat milk to make yogurt.

Method 3: warming without pasteurizing

Some raw-milk advocates make yogurt by warming the milk only to about 100 to 110°F, stirring in a starter and incubating, without any heating that would pasteurize it. Their goal is to keep the milk “raw”. Their claims about retaining beneficial enzymes aren’t well established, and this approach doesn’t reduce the pathogen risk that comes with raw milk.

If you decide to go this way, it is your choice to make, but be clear about what you are accepting. It is not recommended for children, pregnant people, older adults or anyone who is immunocompromised, and it is wise to use milk from a source you know, which is handled and tested carefully and kept cold. Don’t assume the fermentation will make the milk safe.

Texture: why raw milk yogurt can be thin

Raw milk yogurt tends to be runnier than yogurt from heat-treated milk, for two main reasons:

  • No high-heat step. Without it, the whey proteins aren’t changed in the same way, so the gel is looser and more likely to release whey.
  • Competing bacteria. Raw milk has its own natural microbes that can compete with your starter.

If you want thicker raw-milk yogurt without extra heating, strain it. Line a colander with cloth, set it over a bowl, pour in the yogurt and let it drain for a couple of hours or more, depending on how thick you want it. The longer it drains, the thicker it gets. You can use the whey in smoothies or baking. See how to make yogurt at home for straining tips.

Starter and incubation

Handling and storage

  • Keep raw milk cold and use it fresh. Refrigerate promptly at or below 40°F (4°C).
  • Use clean, sanitized equipment.
  • Refrigerate finished yogurt in clean, covered jars.
  • Throw out any batch that smells unpleasant, looks pink or orange, or shows mold.
  • When in doubt, throw it out. Don’t taste-test questionable batches.

Goat and sheep raw milk

Raw goat and sheep milk can be made into yogurt using the same methods, and the same safety considerations apply. Sheep milk is naturally thicker because it has more milk solids. Goat milk tends to give a looser yogurt. See the best milk for yogurt for more on how milk type affects texture.

The complete guide to yogurt basics

How to Make Yogurt at Home: The Complete Beginner's Guide
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →