The short version
Homemade yogurt is usually cheaper per ounce than store-bought, especially if you eat a lot of it or prefer Greek-style or organic. It also gives you control over ingredients and thickness. Store-bought wins on convenience and consistency. Whether homemade is “better” comes down to your household, your local prices and how much you value that control.
Cost: running the numbers
Costs vary by region and store, so treat any figure you read, including those below, as an example rather than a guarantee. Use your own milk and yogurt prices.
Regular yogurt
Homemade yogurt costs about as much as the milk you use, plus a small amount for starter, and a little energy for heating and incubating. A gallon of milk makes close to a gallon of yogurt, since you only set aside a little as starter.
One home cook who makes yogurt for a family of five calculates that a gallon of milk at about $3 to $5 makes around 100 ounces, while buying the same amount would cost somewhere between roughly $15 at a warehouse store and $30 at a regular grocery. Another writer, who buys local milk at a higher price per half gallon and eats about a quart a week, found the savings were closer to pennies a day, since the tubs they were comparing against were cheap.
The takeaway: the more you eat, and the more expensive the yogurt you currently buy, the bigger the savings.
A simple way to check yourself:
- Divide the price of a gallon of milk by 128 ounces to get your cost per ounce of homemade yogurt (a little more, since you lose a bit to starter and spillage).
- Divide the price of the tub you usually buy by the ounces in it.
- Compare.
Greek yogurt and how much a gallon yields
Greek yogurt is where homemade often saves the most, because store-bought Greek is usually priced at a premium. But straining removes whey, so a gallon of milk yields much less Greek yogurt than regular yogurt. How much less depends on how thick you make it. As a rough guide, heavily strained yogurt can end up at around half the original volume or even less. Do the math with your preferred thickness before assuming the savings.
You also get whey as a byproduct, which can be used in smoothies, baking and soups, so little goes to waste if you use it.
Ingredients and nutrition
Is homemade healthier?
Mostly it is similar, with a few differences:
- Added sugar and extras. Plain homemade yogurt has just milk and cultures. Many flavored store-bought yogurts contain added sugar, thickeners or other additives. If you compare homemade plain to store-bought plain, the nutrition is often close.
- Fat and protein. These depend mainly on the milk you use and how much you strain, not on whether the yogurt is homemade.
- Control. At home you decide the milk, the fat level and the thickness.
So “healthier” is often about avoiding added sugar, not about a magic ingredient in homemade yogurt. If you want the healthiest store-bought option, choose plain, unsweetened yogurt with a short ingredient list.
Live cultures
Homemade yogurt that has been freshly cultured contains live bacteria. Store-bought yogurt may or may not, because some products are heat-treated after fermenting. Look for “live and active cultures” on the label. In the US, the Live & Active Cultures seal indicates that a product contained a minimum level of live cultures, reported as 100 million per gram, at the time of manufacture. Counts can decline over time in the container, and the bacteria in any one batch of homemade yogurt aren’t tested, so don’t treat either as a guaranteed probiotic dose.
Taste and texture
Homemade yogurt tends to taste fresher and more tangy, and you can tune it:
- Tartness by adjusting incubation time (shorter is milder, longer is tangier)
- Thickness by choosing the milk, adding milk powder or straining
- Flavor by stirring in fruit, honey or vanilla after it sets
Store-bought yogurt offers a consistent texture batch after batch, which some people prefer. Homemade can vary from batch to batch until you settle on a method. If your results are inconsistent, see common yogurt-making mistakes.
Time and effort
Active work is small, perhaps 20 to 30 minutes of heating, cooling and mixing. The waiting is the long part. From heating the milk to a finished chilled jar can take around a day, mostly unattended. Some people make it overnight and have it ready by morning. A yogurt maker, Instant Pot or insulated cooler can simplify things. See how to make yogurt at home for the method.
Store-bought needs zero prep.
Consistency and safety
When you make yogurt at home, cleanliness is up to you. Use clean jars and utensils, keep the culture healthy and discard any batch that smells or looks off. Over time, a saved starter can weaken, and you may need to restart with fresh culture. See yogurt starter cultures. Store-bought yogurt is made under commercial food-safety controls and has a labeled date.
Who should make their own
Homemade is probably worth trying if:
- You eat a lot of yogurt, especially Greek-style
- You want to avoid added sugar and thickeners
- You like to tinker and have a fridge for long incubation times
- You want to cut down on single-use plastic tubs
Store-bought is probably better if:
- You eat yogurt only occasionally
- You want zero prep
- You buy cheap yogurt on sale and the savings would be small
You can also mix the two: buy plain yogurt as your starter and make your own for most meals.