Cheese and Cultured Dairy

How to Make Cheese from Yogurt at Home

Turn plain or Greek yogurt into soft cheese at home: strained yogurt cheese, cottage-style curds, and how yogurt and cheese really differ.

On this page
  1. Yogurt, cheese and where they overlap
  2. Three ways to make cheese from yogurt
  3. Method 1: Strained yogurt cheese
  4. Method 2: Cottage-style curds from yogurt
  5. Method 3: Using yogurt as a starter
  6. Which yogurt to use
  7. Using the whey
  8. Storage
  9. Common problems
  10. Where to go next

Yogurt, cheese and where they overlap

Yogurt and cheese are both milk that has been changed by acid. In yogurt, live bacteria ferment the lactose and the milk proteins set into a soft gel with the whey still held inside. In most cheeses, the milk is curdled with acid, with rennet, or with both, and the liquid whey is then drained off. The curds that remain are salted, pressed or aged to different degrees.

That is why the two sit on a spectrum rather than in separate boxes. Strain enough whey out of yogurt and you get something that behaves like fresh cheese. Greek yogurt is already part of the way there, which is why it is the easiest starting point.

A few practical differences are worth knowing:

  • Moisture: yogurt is mostly water, while cheese ranges from soft and moist to hard and dry.
  • Process: yogurt is set by fermentation and usually isn’t drained. Cheese depends on separating curds from whey.
  • Keeping time: fresh yogurt cheese is still a fresh, high-moisture product, so it keeps for days, not months.

Three ways to make cheese from yogurt

  1. Strain it. Drain the whey through cloth in the fridge. This is the simplest route and gives yogurt cheese, close to labneh or a homemade cream cheese.
  2. Heat it gently. Warming yogurt makes the curds clump and separate from the whey, giving a crumbly, cottage-style cheese.
  3. Use it as a starter. A spoonful of yogurt can culture a fresh batch of milk, and acid or rennet can then be added to make curds. This is more work, but it is where the cheesemaking skills start to build.

Method 1: Strained yogurt cheese

You need: plain yogurt (whole milk gives the creamiest result), a fine-mesh sieve or colander, cheesecloth or a thin clean cotton cloth, a bowl, and optionally salt.

  1. If you want a savory cheese, stir in salt. A common starting point is about 1 teaspoon per 32 oz (roughly 1 kg) of yogurt. Adjust to taste.
  2. Line the sieve with cloth and set it over a bowl so the bottom doesn’t sit in the whey.
  3. Spoon in the yogurt, fold the cloth over the top and refrigerate.
  4. Drain for 8 to 24 hours for a thick, spreadable result, or up to a couple of days for something firmer that can be rolled into balls.

Greek yogurt drains less, because some whey is already gone. Regular yogurt gives a smaller yield: a rough guide is that a cup of regular yogurt makes about a third to a half cup of cheese, depending on draining time.

Avoid whipping the finished cheese too hard, as it can loosen again. Skimmed or fat-free yogurt works but gives a drier, tarter cheese.

Method 2: Cottage-style curds from yogurt

This method relies on gentle heat. Pour plain yogurt into a saucepan and warm it slowly over low heat, stirring occasionally. Don’t let it boil. After a while the yogurt separates into soft curds and a yellowish whey. Cooking times in recipes vary widely, so go by what you see: when the curds have clearly separated, take the pan off the heat and let it cool.

Pour the mixture into a cloth-lined strainer and drain until the curds are as moist or dry as you like. Add salt to taste. For a creamier “cottage cheese” style, stir in a splash of milk, cream or fresh yogurt.

If you want a more traditional cottage cheese, paneer and the three-ingredient cheese method start from milk instead and give a firmer or more predictable curd. Whole, pasteurized (not UHT) milk is the usual best choice for making curds.

Method 3: Using yogurt as a starter

Live-culture yogurt can add acidity and bacteria to warm milk. You can then add a little acid or rennet to finish the curdling. This is how many farmer’s cheese and quark-style recipes are built. It works with recipes you trust; don’t improvise ratios the first time, because rennet amounts and temperatures matter.

Which yogurt to use

  • Plain only. Flavored yogurt adds sugar and flavorings that you don’t want in cheese.
  • Whole milk for creamy results. Low-fat is fine for a leaner, firmer cheese.
  • Live cultures. Check the label. Yogurt thickened with starch, gelatin or gums may not drain or behave the same way.
  • Avoid very old yogurt. Strained yogurt concentrates sourness and can concentrate off-flavors too.

Using the whey

The liquid that drains off is acid whey. People use it in place of buttermilk or water in bread, pancakes and muffins, in smoothies, or to soak grains. It is also an ingredient in whey ricotta, though yogurt whey gives a small yield on its own. If you don’t plan to use it within a few days, freeze it.

Storage

Keep yogurt cheese in an airtight container in the fridge. About a week is a typical guide for plain strained yogurt cheese. Labneh balls covered in oil should stay refrigerated and be eaten within a short time. If it develops pink or orange patches, fuzzy mold, or an off smell, discard it.

Common problems

My Greek yogurt tastes cheesy. Greek yogurt is strained, which concentrates both the tang and the milk solids, so a slightly cheese-like flavor and texture is normal. A strong sour or yeasty smell is different and may mean it is past its best.

What’s the most common mistake when making yogurt? Usually it is temperature: milk that is too hot kills the culture, milk that is too cool sets slowly, and moving the jar while it sets can break the gel. A thin, runny or grainy result is often down to one of those.

The cheese is grainy. Over-heating in the cottage-style method is the usual cause. Lower the heat and stop earlier.

The cheese is too runny. Drain it for longer, or press it gently under a light weight.

The cheese is too sour. Start with fresher yogurt, or use a milder, whole-milk yogurt.

Where to go next

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →