Why coconut milk is different
Coconut milk contains no lactose, and L. reuteri long-ferment recipes normally rely on milk sugar plus a prebiotic. In coconut milk you usually add a small amount of sugar or honey along with the inulin so the bacteria have something to eat. Dr. William Davis notes that the finished yogurt should have little sugar left, since it is fermented to lactic acid, and that you can ferment a few more hours if in doubt.
Coconut milk is also fussier than dairy. The fat can separate, and Davis suggests emulsifying canned coconut milk (for example with an immersion blender) before adding the starter. Fermenting coconut milk calls for steadier temperature control than dairy does, so use a yogurt maker or sous vide rather than the oven trick.
Ingredients
This follows the most common version of the recipe, for about 1.2 litres.
- 3 cans (400 ml each) full-fat coconut milk, or a mix of milk and cream, with no unwanted additives
- 2 teaspoons agar-agar powder (or about 1½ tablespoons of beef gelatin)
- 3 crushed L. reuteri tablets (BioGaia Gastrus is commonly used) or 1 sachet of L. reuteri starter
- 2 tablespoons inulin powder
- 1 teaspoon white sugar or 1 tablespoon pasteurized honey
Canned coconut milk, not the carton kind, is the type recommended.
Method
- Wash and scald your pot, whisk, jars and utensils so unwanted bacteria don’t take over a long ferment.
- Whisk the agar-agar into the coconut milk, then heat to about 190°F (87°C) for 5 minutes, whisking all the time so it doesn’t stick or scorch.
- Remove from the heat and cool to below about 108°F (42°C). Cooling to 100°F (38°C) or less is safer.
- Crush the tablets to a fine powder and mix with the inulin and sugar or honey. Stir in about ¼ cup of the cooled coconut milk until smooth, then whisk the slurry into the rest.
- Pour into clean jars, cover loosely and ferment at roughly 98–100°F (36–38°C) for 24 to 36 hours.
- Chill for at least 6 hours. Whisk or briefly blend for a smoother texture if needed.
Throw the batch away if it smells off, fizzes strongly or shows pink or other unusual colors. If you plan to serve it to anyone with a weak immune system, check with a clinician first. Honey should not be given to babies under one year.
Tips for a smoother result
- Expect it to be thinner and less uniform than dairy yogurt, especially in the first batch.
- Use a thermometer to confirm your device’s real temperature. See our guide to the right temperature for L. reuteri yogurt.
- Whisk rather than blend the starter slurry; blending is for after fermentation.
- Some makers blend in soaked cashews with a gum such as guar for body.
Coconut yogurt vs Greek yogurt
Which is healthier depends on what you need. Greek yogurt generally has more protein and less saturated fat than coconut yogurt, while coconut yogurt is dairy-free and suits people avoiding milk. Homemade versions vary, so neither is universally healthier. If you have a milk allergy or follow a medical diet, ask your doctor or dietitian.
You can also use dairy for this style of yogurt: see using whole milk and half-and-half or cream.
Can you buy yogurt with L. reuteri?
Ordinary store-bought yogurt and kefir are made with other cultures and generally do not contain L. reuteri. Some specialty products may list it, so check the label for the species and strain. For a reliably L. reuteri product, most people make it at home from tablets or a starter, as in this recipe.