What makes a yogurt starter SCD-legal
The Specific Carbohydrate Diet (SCD) allows yogurt only if it is fermented long enough that most of the lactose is consumed, which is why the usual instruction is a 24-hour ferment. The starter matters too. Sources describing SCD-legal starters generally say it should contain:
- Lactobacillus bulgaricus
- Streptococcus thermophilus
- often Lactobacillus acidophilus or Lactobacillus casei
and should not contain any Bifidobacterium (“bifidus”) strains such as B. bifidum, B. infantis or B. longum. Check the label for added sugars, gums or fillers, which are also not allowed on the diet. Rules differ between SCD resources, so check the one you follow.
Choosing a starter
- Dedicated SCD-legal starters. Examples that appear in the search results include GI ProStart (made by GI ProHealth) and an SCD-legal culture from Know-How Foods, which lists L. bulgaricus, S. thermophilus and L. casei. Custom Probiotics also sells a three-strain powder without bifidobacteria. Prices change, so check the seller.
- Plain commercial yogurt as a starter. Some people use a plain, additive-free yogurt that lists only legal live cultures. Read the culture list carefully, since many yogurts add bifidobacteria or other strains.
- Dairy or non-dairy. Some starters are sold for both. Non-dairy milks lack lactose, so they follow different rules.
Starter amounts vary by product. One listing suggests about 1/8 teaspoon for 2 quarts of dairy milk. Always follow the package.
Ingredients and equipment
- Milk (follow your diet’s guidance on what type is allowed)
- SCD-legal starter
- A clean glass jar or jars
- A yogurt maker or another way to hold a steady, warm temperature
- A thermometer
Making 24-hour yogurt
This is the usual outline, based on how conventional yogurt cultures are used. Your starter’s instructions take priority.
- Clean the jar and tools.
- Heat the milk to about 180°F (82°C), then let it cool to the temperature your starter specifies. Conventional cultures generally work at roughly 100–110°F (38–43°C).
- Stir the starter into a little of the warm milk, then mix into the rest.
- Keep the jar at the recommended temperature for 24 hours without stirring or moving it.
- Refrigerate to chill and firm it up.
Fermenting for 24 hours is meant to use up lactose, but you can’t confirm this at home, so people with a strong lactose sensitivity should treat it as an approximation.
Troubleshooting
- Thin or runny: 24-hour yogurt tends to be tart and can be thinner than store yogurt. Straining some of the whey makes it thicker.
- Not setting at all: check that your yogurt maker holds the right temperature, and that the starter is within its date.
- Smells off or shows pink or fuzzy growth: discard it.
Notes on diet and health
SCD is a medical-style diet usually followed for digestive conditions. Talk to your doctor or dietitian about whether it suits you and whether homemade yogurt fits in. Nothing on this page is medical advice.
Related guides
- How to make probiotic yogurt from capsules, a different starter route (note that many capsules contain strains SCD does not allow)
- L. reuteri yogurt side effects