The best yogurt maker for L. reuteri yogurt is one that holds a steady temperature of about 100°F (roughly 36°C to 38°C) for 36 to 48 hours. Most basic machines run hotter than that or stop after a shorter timer, so the features to look for are adjustable temperature and a long timer.
What L. reuteri yogurt needs
Lactobacillus reuteri is a different organism from the bacteria in ordinary yogurt, and recipes for it differ from a standard overnight batch. Typical instructions call for:
- a lower incubation temperature, commonly around 100°F, than the roughly 108°F to 115°F used for regular yogurt
- a long incubation, commonly 36 to 48 hours
- a starter made from L. reuteri tablets or capsules sold for this purpose, rather than from ordinary store-bought yogurt
- a rich base, with recipes frequently using half-and-half or whole milk
Methods and timing vary between recipes and culture suppliers, so follow the instructions that come with your culture. This article only covers the equipment side.
What to look for in a machine
- Adjustable temperature. A fixed-temperature machine that runs near 110°F or above is the wrong tool. You want a range that includes the high 90s Fahrenheit.
- A long timer. Many basic machines cap out at around 12 to 15 hours. A timer that reaches 36 to 48 hours means you do not have to restart it.
- Even, stable heating. Water-bath designs surround the jar with warmed water and tend to hold temperature steadily.
- Glass or ceramic containers. Easy to sanitize, which matters over a long ferment.
- Enough capacity for the batch size you plan to make.
Machines people commonly use
These are reported in buying guides and community discussions, and details and prices change, so verify the current specifications before buying.
- Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker (roughly $60 to $90): often cited for an adjustable range of about 68°F to 131°F and a timer of up to 48 hours. It is sold with either two 1-quart containers or a set of 6-oz glass jars. Some owners report concerns about plastic quality and temperature swings.
- Luvele Pure Plus (roughly $125): uses a water-bath design with a 2.1-quart (2 L) glass container and a long, adjustable timer. The brand also publishes its own L. reuteri recipe. It costs more but is frequently recommended for steady temperatures.
- Other adjustable machines: several lesser-known models offer temperature control with a roughly 36-hour cycle and six small borosilicate jars. If you consider one, check reviews for temperature accuracy.
Machines that are usually a poor fit
- Basic single-temperature models and short timers. Machines like the Euro Cuisine YMX650 work well for standard overnight yogurt but have a timer that tops out at about 15 hours, and they run at one fixed temperature. See our Euro Cuisine yogurt maker review.
- Older or basic multi-cookers without custom temperature. Some run hotter than 100°F or limit how long a cycle can run.
For standard yogurt, a simple machine is fine. Our guide to the best yogurt makers compares the general-purpose options.
Alternatives to a dedicated machine
- Sous vide circulator. If you own one, it can hold a water bath at a precise temperature for as long as you like. See sous vide yogurt for the setup, though you would use the L. reuteri temperature rather than the standard one.
- Multi-cooker with a custom temperature setting. Some models allow you to set a specific temperature and time; check your model’s range.
- Insulated cooler with warm water. Possible but harder to keep steady over 36 hours or more.
Tips
- Test the temperature first. Run the machine with water and a thermometer in a jar for a few hours. Displays and settings are not always accurate.
- Keep everything clean. A long, warm ferment gives unwanted bacteria time to grow. Wash and sanitize jars and utensils thoroughly, and discard any batch with an off smell, pink or orange discoloration, or visible mold.
- Don’t open the jars. Leave them undisturbed for the full time.
- Chill after fermenting. Refrigerate promptly.
A health note
People make L. reuteri yogurt for a range of reasons, but this site cannot say what it will or won’t do for any individual. If you have a health condition, are pregnant, or have a weakened immune system, talk to your doctor before consuming homemade, long-fermented probiotic foods.