The hardest part of homemade yogurt is keeping the milk at a steady, gentle temperature for hours. An immersion circulator does exactly that, which is why many cooks who own one use it for yogurt instead of buying a dedicated machine (see do you really need a yogurt maker?).
Why sous vide suits yogurt
A circulator holds a water bath within a degree or so of its set temperature. Compared with an oven with the light on or a towel-wrapped pot, that means fewer temperature swings and more repeatable batches. It can also do the heating step, and it can hold the bath at a lower temperature for specialty ferments.
What you need
- A sous vide immersion circulator and a pot or container large enough to submerge the jars
- Milk: a half gallon makes about two quarts. Whole milk gives a thicker, richer yogurt, while 2% and skim are thinner.
- Starter: roughly 1/2 cup of plain yogurt with live and active cultures per half gallon, or a packet of starter following its instructions. Some recipes use a smaller amount of a thicker yogurt.
- Clean glass jars (quart size or smaller), a thermometer, and ice
- Optional: powdered milk, cheesecloth and a strainer
About the milk: ultra-pasteurized (UP or UHT) milk has been heated to very high temperatures. It can still make yogurt if you add a starter, but often sets more softly than regular pasteurized milk. Raw milk is used by some people, but food-safety rules differ, so consider the risks and local law before using it.
Step by step
- Heat the milk to about 180°F (82°C). You can do this in the circulator by setting the bath to 180°F and heating the milk in jars or a bag, then holding it there for about 30 minutes. Heating changes the milk proteins so the yogurt sets thicker. Some cooks skip the hold, but many find the set is better with it.
- Cool below 110°F (43°C). Add ice to the water bath, or move the jars to an ice bath, until the milk is below about 110°F. Starter added to milk that is too hot may die.
- Add the starter. Whisk a splash of the cooled milk into the starter, then stir that mixture into the rest of the milk.
- Jar it. Pour into clean jars and put the lids on fingertip-tight, not forced shut, so pressure does not build.
- Set the bath. Reset the circulator to between about 108°F and 115°F and let the water reach that temperature.
- Incubate. Submerge the jars with the water level above the milk. A lid or floating cover on the pot reduces evaporation. Leave them for 5 to 24 hours, depending on the flavor you want. Do not move them around while they set.
- Chill. Move the jars to the fridge, preferably overnight, so the yogurt firms up.
Temperature and time guide
Recipes differ, but a common pattern is:
| Incubation | Result |
|---|---|
| About 5 to 10 hours | Milder flavor and a softer set |
| About 12 to 24 hours | Tangier flavor and firmer set |
| Closer to 115°F | Often a firmer set |
| Closer to 108°F to 110°F | Often a softer, more pourable yogurt |
One well-known recipe uses 110°F for 12 hours with small jars. See how long it takes to make yogurt for more on how time changes the result. If you want to ferment at a lower temperature for a long time, such as for L. reuteri yogurt, a circulator can hold that, but follow the culture’s own instructions.
Heating on the stove or in the bath
Both work. Heating in the bath is hands-off and avoids scorched pots, but a large volume of milk in a water bath can take a long time to come up to temperature, and your circulator’s heating power matters. Heating on the stove, stirring constantly, is faster and uses less energy, then you can use the circulator only for incubation. Cooks disagree about which is better, and neither is wrong.
Making it thicker
- Use whole milk
- Stir in a small amount of powdered milk after cooling, if you like
- Strain the chilled yogurt through cheesecloth or a fine mesh for a Greek-style yogurt, usually for a few hours in the fridge
Our Instant Pot Greek yogurt guide covers straining in more detail.
Troubleshooting
- Yogurt didn’t set: Check that the milk was below about 110°F when you added the starter, that the starter was live and active, and that the bath really held the temperature.
- Too tangy: Shorten the incubation time next time.
- Too thin: Use whole milk, hold the heated milk at 180°F, or strain it.
- Water evaporating: Cover the pot, or use floating balls or a lid designed for your container.
- Jars floating or tipping: Weigh them down with a rack or clean weights.
Pros and cons
Pros: precise, repeatable temperature; large batches in multiple jars; no new appliance if you already own a circulator.
Cons: you need a circulator; heating a large amount of milk takes time; the bath ties up your circulator for many hours.
If you do not own a circulator, the slow cooker method or a dedicated yogurt maker may suit you better.