Most yogurt makers take about 6 to 12 hours to culture a batch, and 8 to 10 hours is a common choice for standard yogurt. Culturing for longer, up to around 24 hours, gives a tangier and often firmer yogurt. Add the time for preparing the milk and for chilling, and the whole process usually runs about 12 to 16 hours from start to spoon.
A typical timeline
| Stage | Typical time |
|---|---|
| Heat milk to about 180°F (82°C) | 10 to 30 minutes, depending on pot and quantity |
| Cool to about 110°F (43°C) | 30 to 45 minutes, faster in an ice bath |
| Add starter and fill jars or container | 5 to 10 minutes |
| Incubate in the machine | 6 to 12 hours (up to 24 for tangier yogurt) |
| Chill in the fridge | At least 3 to 6 hours, or overnight |
| Optional: strain for Greek-style | About 2 to 4 hours, longer for thicker |
Your machine’s manual should have its own recommended time, and it is a better starting point than any general figure. For example, the Euro Cuisine jar machines are commonly described as taking 6 to 10 hours, with a timer that can go to roughly 15 hours. See our Euro Cuisine yogurt maker review.
How culturing time changes the result
- About 4 to 8 hours: a milder flavor and a softer, looser set. If you like gentle tartness, start checking in this range.
- About 8 to 12 hours: the classic balance of creaminess and tang. Many people find this range works well for overnight batches.
- About 12 to 24 hours: noticeably tangier and usually firmer. Some people use longer times because the milk sugar is used up further, but the yogurt can also separate more.
Longer is not automatically better. Very long incubation in a machine that runs warm can produce sour, grainy yogurt with a lot of liquid whey on top.
What changes the time
- Temperature. Cultures work faster in the warmer part of their range and slower when cooler. A machine that runs warm may finish sooner, and one that runs cool may need longer.
- Starter amount and freshness. A fresh, active starter in the right quantity sets sooner. Old or weak starter can take longer or fail.
- Milk type. Whole milk usually sets thicker than skim. Ultra-pasteurized milk and some plant milks behave differently.
- Batch size. Larger batches of milk take longer to reach and hold temperature.
- Whether the milk was heated. Heating to about 180°F before culturing helps the yogurt set firmer.
How to tell it’s done
Tilt a jar gently. Finished yogurt moves as one mass, pulls slightly from the side of the container, and may have a thin layer of clear whey on top. It should smell pleasantly tangy. It will still be loose when warm and will thicken in the fridge, so do not judge it by the warm texture alone. Avoid stirring or shaking while it is culturing.
Chilling and straining
Refrigerate the finished yogurt for at least a few hours, or overnight, before eating so it firms up. To make Greek-style yogurt, strain the chilled yogurt through cheesecloth or a fine mesh. Many recipes strain for about 2 to 4 hours, while some go for a day or more for a very thick result. For more detail, see our guide to making Greek yogurt in an Instant Pot, which applies to any batch.
Special cases
- L. reuteri yogurt needs a lower temperature, around 100°F, and a much longer ferment of roughly 36 to 48 hours. Standard machines with a 15-hour cap are not suitable. See which yogurt maker is best for L. reuteri yogurt.
- Slow cooker, oven and sous vide methods have similar culturing times, typically about 6 to 12 hours. See yogurt in a slow cooker, yogurt in the oven with the light on and sous vide yogurt.
If it isn’t setting
Check these common causes before leaving it for longer:
- The milk was too hot when you added the starter, which can kill the cultures.
- The starter was old, inactive or not labeled “live and active cultures”.
- The machine is running too cool. Check with a thermometer.
- You used too much starter or disturbed the jars.
- The milk was ultra-pasteurized or low-fat.
If the yogurt is still runny after the recommended time, extra time may help a little, but if there is no sign of setting after 12 hours or so, and especially if it smells off, it is safer to discard it and start again.