Probiotic Yogurt

L. Reuteri Yogurt with Half-and-Half or Cream: Recipe and Tips

Make L. reuteri yogurt with half-and-half or cream: ingredients, method, how to adjust thickness with milk or cream, storage and troubleshooting tips.

On this page
  1. Why half-and-half
  2. What counts as half-and-half
  3. Ingredients
  4. Method
  5. Adjusting thickness with milk or cream
  6. Storage and reculturing
  7. Troubleshooting
  8. Related guides

Why half-and-half

Dr. William Davis created his L. reuteri method with half-and-half, and says it gives a thick, rich end result, something like cream cheese. He says whole milk gives a thinner result like store yogurt, while straight cream produces something close to butter, too thick for his taste. Luvele recommends following the original half-and-half method where it is available, based on feedback that it gives reliable results.

What counts as half-and-half

Half-and-half is a US product made of roughly equal parts whole milk and light cream. In other countries it may be sold as half cream or light cream, or not at all. If you can’t find it:

  • Mix equal parts whole milk and light cream yourself. Luvele notes that homemade blends need heating first or they may come out thin and separated.
  • Use ultra-pasteurized (UHT) whole milk, see our whole milk guide.
  • Look at the fat percentage on the label and aim for something close to a half-and-half.

Ingredients

  • 1 quart (about 1 litre) ultra-pasteurized half-and-half, or a combination of half-and-half and ultra-pasteurized whole milk for a semi-firm result
  • 2 tablespoons of prebiotic fiber such as inulin (see the inulin guide)
  • L. reuteri starter: one sachet, 10 crushed BioGaia Gastrus tablets as in Davis’s recipe (Luvele uses 3), or 2 tablespoons of a previous batch

Method

  1. Clean your jar and utensils.
  2. If the half-and-half is not ultra-pasteurized, heat it to about 180–195°F (82–90°C), hold for 10 to 30 minutes, then cool to below about 107°F (42°C).
  3. In a bowl, mix the prebiotic and starter with 5 to 6 tablespoons of the milk to make a slurry. Use a whisk, not a power blender.
  4. Whisk in the rest of the half-and-half.
  5. Pour into jars, cover loosely with plastic wrap or loose lids, and ferment at about 100°F (38°C) for 36 hours. Keep the jars away from vents and drafts, and don’t stir.
  6. When done, refrigerate with the lids loose. If you tighten the lids while warm, gas can build up and may break glass jars. Once cold, tighten.

Our temperature guide covers how to check your yogurt maker.

Adjusting thickness with milk or cream

  • Thicker: add some cream. Davis found pure cream too thick, so blend it.
  • Thinner or milder: blend half-and-half with whole milk.
  • Per Davis: avoid low-fat and skim, which give thin results.

Storage and reculturing

One recipe source says the yogurt keeps in the fridge for up to 4 weeks; other makers give shorter times, so use your judgment and discard anything that smells or looks off. To make the next batch, use about 2 tablespoons of this one, or 1 tablespoon each of whey and curds if it separated. Luvele suggests starting afresh after 4 to 5 recultures, while Davis’s group often cites about 20. Restart sooner if the taste, smell or texture changes.

Troubleshooting

  • Separated first batch: common. Stir the whey back in or strain it, and use some for the next batch.
  • Yellow or pink film on top: a recipe author describes a harmless yeast that can be scraped off, but if the batch smells off, throw it away.
  • Runny: check the device temperature and whether the milk was heated if it wasn’t ultra-pasteurized.

The complete guide to probiotic yogurt

How to Make Probiotic Yogurt from Capsules
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →