Short answer
Yes. You can make L. reuteri yogurt with whole milk. Dr. William Davis’s original method used half-and-half, and he says whole milk gives a thinner end result, similar to store-bought yogurt in consistency, while half-and-half gives something closer to cream cheese. Many people use whole milk anyway because it is cheaper and easier to find. The main rule is to avoid low-fat and skim.
How whole milk compares with half-and-half
- Texture: thinner, and more likely to separate into curds and whey, especially in the first batches.
- Richness: less rich than half-and-half.
- Cost and availability: whole milk is cheaper and available everywhere, whereas half-and-half is mainly a US product.
Luvele recommends half-and-half where available, with UHT or organic milk as the fallback elsewhere. See our page on half-and-half and cream if you want the richer version.
Preparing whole milk
- Check the type. Ultra-pasteurized (UHT) whole milk can often go straight in, cold, with no heating step.
- Heat regular pasteurized milk first. Heat to about 180–195°F (82–90°C) and hold for 10 to 30 minutes. This helps the proteins bond and thicken, and reduces competing bacteria.
- Cool it. Let it fall below about 107°F (42°C) before adding the starter. It is fine if it cools further.
- Add prebiotic fiber. Most recipes add about 2 tablespoons of inulin per quart. See our inulin guide.
- Ferment at about 97–100°F (36–38°C), for up to 36 hours, then chill for at least 6 hours. See the temperature guide.
Getting a thicker result
- Use ultra-pasteurized milk, or heat ordinary milk properly.
- Mix in a little cream. A blend of whole milk and cream is a middle path.
- Some sources say A2 whole milk or a small amount of milk powder can reduce separation. This is anecdotal.
- Keep reculturing: batches often improve over the first few rounds.
- If it still separates, strain off the whey for a thicker, Greek-style result. The whey contains bacteria too, so it can be stirred back in or used in smoothies.
Milks to avoid or treat carefully
- Skim, low-fat and 2%: generally too thin.
- Raw milk: one blogger reports keeping milk raw and getting a good result after several batches, but raw milk carries food-safety risks, particularly in a 36-hour warm ferment. We do not recommend it.
- Goat and sheep milk: both are used. Goat milk yogurt tends to be thinner.
- Plant milks: see our coconut milk version; other plant milks are generally too thin.