Probiotic Yogurt

Can you use whole milk to make L-reuteri yogurt?

Yes, whole milk works for L. reuteri yogurt. Learn how it compares with half-and-half, whether to heat it, and how to get a thicker, less separated batch.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. How whole milk compares with half-and-half
  3. Preparing whole milk
  4. Getting a thicker result
  5. Milks to avoid or treat carefully
  6. Related guides

Short answer

Yes. You can make L. reuteri yogurt with whole milk. Dr. William Davis’s original method used half-and-half, and he says whole milk gives a thinner end result, similar to store-bought yogurt in consistency, while half-and-half gives something closer to cream cheese. Many people use whole milk anyway because it is cheaper and easier to find. The main rule is to avoid low-fat and skim.

How whole milk compares with half-and-half

  • Texture: thinner, and more likely to separate into curds and whey, especially in the first batches.
  • Richness: less rich than half-and-half.
  • Cost and availability: whole milk is cheaper and available everywhere, whereas half-and-half is mainly a US product.

Luvele recommends half-and-half where available, with UHT or organic milk as the fallback elsewhere. See our page on half-and-half and cream if you want the richer version.

Preparing whole milk

  1. Check the type. Ultra-pasteurized (UHT) whole milk can often go straight in, cold, with no heating step.
  2. Heat regular pasteurized milk first. Heat to about 180–195°F (82–90°C) and hold for 10 to 30 minutes. This helps the proteins bond and thicken, and reduces competing bacteria.
  3. Cool it. Let it fall below about 107°F (42°C) before adding the starter. It is fine if it cools further.
  4. Add prebiotic fiber. Most recipes add about 2 tablespoons of inulin per quart. See our inulin guide.
  5. Ferment at about 97–100°F (36–38°C), for up to 36 hours, then chill for at least 6 hours. See the temperature guide.

Getting a thicker result

  • Use ultra-pasteurized milk, or heat ordinary milk properly.
  • Mix in a little cream. A blend of whole milk and cream is a middle path.
  • Some sources say A2 whole milk or a small amount of milk powder can reduce separation. This is anecdotal.
  • Keep reculturing: batches often improve over the first few rounds.
  • If it still separates, strain off the whey for a thicker, Greek-style result. The whey contains bacteria too, so it can be stirred back in or used in smoothies.

Milks to avoid or treat carefully

  • Skim, low-fat and 2%: generally too thin.
  • Raw milk: one blogger reports keeping milk raw and getting a good result after several batches, but raw milk carries food-safety risks, particularly in a 36-hour warm ferment. We do not recommend it.
  • Goat and sheep milk: both are used. Goat milk yogurt tends to be thinner.
  • Plant milks: see our coconut milk version; other plant milks are generally too thin.

The complete guide to probiotic yogurt

How to Make Probiotic Yogurt from Capsules
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →