Yogurt Troubleshooting

Mold, Yeast and Shelf Life: When Homemade Yogurt Has Gone Bad

How to spot mold, pink discoloration and yeast in yogurt, why you should not scrape it off, and how long homemade and opened yogurt generally keeps.

On this page
  1. Quick answer
  2. Mold in yogurt
  3. Pink or orange discoloration
  4. Yeast in yogurt
  5. How long does homemade yogurt last?
  6. Store-bought yogurt after opening
  7. Preventing contamination
  8. Decision table

Quick answer

Throw yogurt away if you see fuzzy mold, pink, orange or gray discoloration, a yeasty or rotten smell, or fizzing and bulging in a product that should not fizz. Do not scrape the spoiled part off and eat the rest. As a conservative guide, plan to eat homemade yogurt within about a week, and opened store-bought yogurt within about a week to ten days, using the printed date and your senses as a check.

Mold in yogurt

Yogurt is moist and soft, so mold roots can spread beyond what you can see. Mold may look:

  • Fuzzy or powdery in white, green, blue, gray or black
  • Like colored dots or patches on the surface or under the lid

If you spot any of these, discard the whole container. Scraping off the top layer does not make the rest safe. Avoid sniffing the container up close, because mold spores can irritate the airways.

Pink or orange discoloration

Pink, salmon or orange patches in yogurt are often linked to pigmented microbes, such as the bacterium Serratia marcescens or yeasts such as Rhodotorula. They are usually a sign of contamination from the environment, equipment or hands. Do not eat it. Our dedicated article on pink, orange or gray spots in yogurt goes into causes and prevention.

For homemade yogurt, the practical lesson is sanitation. Wash jars, lids and tools well and scald them with boiling water, or use a dishwasher sanitize cycle, right before use. Some makers also refresh their starter periodically with a new culture.

Yeast in yogurt

Yeasts are different from yogurt bacteria. Unwanted yeast can grow in yogurt, especially if it contains added sugar or fruit, or if it has been stored too long. Signs include:

  • A yeasty, bread-like, beer-like or wine-like smell
  • Fizziness or small bubbles
  • A puffed lid or bulging foil seal
  • A noticeably sour or off taste that is not the usual lactic tang

Discard yogurt showing these signs. If you only see a normal, slightly tangy flavor and no bubbles or smell, it is likely fine. Our article on why yogurt tastes sour, cheesy or fizzy explains the difference between normal tang and trouble.

Note that the phrase “yogurt yeast” is sometimes used for yogurt starter culture. That is bacteria, not yeast, and it is not a contamination problem.

How long does homemade yogurt last?

Homemade yogurt has no preservatives, and its keeping time depends on how clean the equipment was and how cold the fridge is. A practical rule is to eat it within about a week. Keep these points in mind:

  • Chill it promptly once it has set, and keep it at or below 40°F (4°C).
  • Use clean spoons. Do not eat straight from the jar and then put it back.
  • Do not leave it out. The general food safety rule is no more than two hours at room temperature, or one hour if the room is above 90°F (32°C). See whether yogurt is safe after fermenting overnight or left out too long.
  • Freezing extends storage, though the texture changes after thawing, so thawed yogurt works best in smoothies and baking.

Store-bought yogurt after opening

Sources vary. Some give about 5–7 days after opening, others up to 7–14 days. A cautious reading is to aim to finish an opened container within about a week, and to avoid relying on a date alone. Date labels such as “best by” or “sell by” mostly concern quality, not a precise safety cutoff, but a container that has been mishandled or warmed up can spoil sooner.

For ideas on using yogurt that is near or past its date, read what to do with expired yogurt. Clear liquid on top is usually just whey; see why yogurt separates.

Preventing contamination

  • Wash and sanitize jars, lids, thermometers and spoons before each batch.
  • Heat the milk properly and let it cool in a covered container.
  • Use fresh, active starter and replace it if you suspect contamination.
  • Avoid adding sugar or fruit to the batch before incubation.
  • Keep the fridge cold and the lid tight.
  • Make smaller batches if you do not eat yogurt quickly.

Decision table

What you notice What to do
Fuzzy mold Discard the whole container
Pink, orange or gray spots Discard
Yeasty smell, bubbles or bulging lid Discard
Slimy and off-smelling Discard
Clear liquid on top, normal smell Stir in or pour off
Slightly more tart after several days Probably fine if it smells clean
Left out for hours Discard

The complete guide to yogurt troubleshooting

Homemade Yogurt Problems: Curdled, Grainy and Slimy Yogurt Fixed
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →