Greek and Strained Yogurt

Why is Greek yogurt so expensive?

Greek yogurt costs more mainly because straining removes whey, so each tub needs more milk, plus extra processing. See what drives the price and how to pay less.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Straining means more milk per tub
  3. Extra processing, equipment and handling
  4. Demand, branding and general costs
  5. Why Greek-style tubs can cost less
  6. Ways to pay less
  7. Is homemade cheaper?

The short answer

Greek yogurt is mostly more expensive than regular yogurt because making it uses more milk. Straining drains off a large share of the liquid, so a producer has to start with a lot more milk to fill each tub. Extra processing, demand for high-protein foods, and general food and transport costs add to the price.

Straining means more milk per tub

Regular yogurt keeps most of the liquid it is made with. Greek yogurt loses a good part of that liquid as whey. Industry and home cooks alike often describe the loss as roughly half the volume or more, depending on how thick the final product is. In other words, a tub of Greek yogurt can take about twice as much milk, or more, as a tub of regular yogurt of the same size.

Milk is the main raw ingredient, so a higher milk input per tub translates fairly directly into a higher shelf price. You can see the same effect at home: if you strain a quart of yogurt well, you’ll end up with noticeably less than a quart. For an estimate, see how much Greek yogurt a gallon of milk makes.

Extra processing, equipment and handling

Draining whey takes additional steps. Depending on the producer, that can mean cloth bags, centrifuges or ultrafiltration equipment, plus the time, energy and labor to run them. Then there is the whey itself, which has to be handled or sold on as a by-product, since producers end up with a lot of it.

Demand, branding and general costs

Greek yogurt became popular partly because it is high in protein, and strong demand supports higher prices. Branding, packaging and marketing add to the cost, as do refrigerated transport and storage. General grocery inflation has pushed prices up across dairy.

Why Greek-style tubs can cost less

Some products labeled “Greek-style” are not strained as much. They are thickened with milk solids, starches or other additives, which avoids the large milk loss. That can make them cheaper, but with different ingredients, and often less protein, than strained yogurt. We compare them in Greek yogurt vs Greek-style vs regular yogurt. Whether the processing matters to you is another question, covered in Is Greek yogurt highly processed?

Ways to pay less

  • Buy larger tubs. Multi-serving tubs generally cost less per ounce than single-serve cups.
  • Try store brands. Private-label Greek yogurt is often cheaper than national brands.
  • Buy plain, not flavored. Plain yogurt is usually cheaper, and you can add fruit or honey yourself.
  • Compare unit prices, not just the sticker price on the tub.
  • Make your own. It takes a little time but few ingredients.

Is homemade cheaper?

Often it can be, since you pay for milk and a spoonful of starter, with no packaging, branding or extra processing. (We compare the two in homemade vs store-bought yogurt.) Because straining reduces the volume, though, your cost per cup of finished Greek yogurt depends on the price of your milk and how thick you want it. Another way to stretch your budget is to use the whey, which you can put to work in smoothies, baking and more. See what to do with leftover whey. To try it, start with our guide to making thick Greek yogurt at home.

The complete guide to greek and strained yogurt

How to Make Thick Greek Yogurt at Home
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →