The short answer
A gallon of milk typically makes about 5 to 8 cups of Greek yogurt, which is roughly 1.3 to 2 quarts (about 1.2 to 1.9 liters). Before straining, a gallon makes a little over a gallon of regular yogurt once the starter is added. Straining then removes a large share of the volume as whey, usually somewhere between half and two-thirds of it, depending on how thick you want the result.
These are estimates. Your yield will depend on the milk, the yogurt and how long you strain, so treat the numbers as a planning guide, not a guarantee.
Yield by thickness
A gallon is 4 quarts, or 16 cups.
| Stage | Approximate amount from 1 gallon of milk |
|---|---|
| Regular, unstrained yogurt | About 1 gallon (16 cups), plus a little for the starter |
| Lightly strained (thick, still loose) | Roughly 8-10 cups |
| Greek-style thick | Roughly 6-8 cups |
| Very thick or cheese-like (long strain) | Roughly 4-6 cups, or less |
Whey makes up the difference. A heavily strained batch can lose well over half its volume.
Why you lose so much volume
Yogurt is mostly water. When you strain it, the watery whey drains out, leaving behind the protein, fat and some of the sugar. Greek yogurt is thicker precisely because more of the water has gone. That is also why Greek yogurt costs more per tub than regular yogurt in stores: it takes more milk to make the same amount. See why Greek yogurt is so expensive.
What changes the yield
- Straining time. The longer you strain, the less you get, and the thicker it becomes.
- Milk fat. Whole milk yogurt tends to set thicker to begin with, so it may need less straining to reach the same texture. Nonfat or low-fat milk often needs more.
- How firmly the yogurt set. A firmly set batch loses its whey more slowly.
- Squeezing. Pressing or wringing a cloth bundle removes more whey and reduces the yield.
- Heating the milk well. Heating to about 180°F can help the yogurt set thicker, so less straining is needed.
Making a gallon batch
A gallon of milk is a large batch and a few details become more important:
- Pot size. Use a heavy pot with room to spare so the milk doesn’t boil over or scorch.
- Starter. A common rule of thumb is roughly 2 tablespoons of starter per quart, which is about 1/2 cup per gallon. Follow the guidance for your own culture.
- Cooling time. A gallon takes much longer to cool to about 110°F than a small batch does. An ice bath helps.
- Incubation. Large volumes hold heat well, but still keep them warm and undisturbed. Follow the same times and checks in our guide to making thick Greek yogurt at home.
- Straining in stages. A big batch is easier to strain in two or three lined strainers, or in several smaller containers.
Don’t waste the whey
A gallon batch can leave you with several cups of whey, so plan for it. It is useful in smoothies, doughs, cooking grains and more. See what to do with leftover whey. If you have no cheesecloth for a big batch, a clean cotton towel or nut milk bag works well. See how to strain Greek yogurt without cheesecloth.
A note on cost
To find your cost per cup, divide the price of the gallon of milk by the number of cups of Greek yogurt you end up with. Because yields vary, it’s worth weighing or measuring your first batch. Do it once and you’ll have a reliable number for your own recipe.