How plant-milk yogurt differs from dairy yogurt
Dairy yogurt sets because milk contains protein (casein) that gels as bacteria produce acid, and it contains lactose for those bacteria to eat. Plant milks behave differently. Most have less protein that gels well, and most contain little or no lactose, so you usually need to add a little sugar for the cultures and often a thickener for body.
The good news is that the overall process is the same for every plant milk: warm the milk, add live cultures, hold it warm for several hours, then chill. The details change from milk to milk, which is why this site has a recipe for each one.
Choosing a plant milk
- Soy milk is the most forgiving. It has more protein than most other plant milks and generally sets more firmly. See the soy yogurt recipe.
- Coconut milk (full-fat, canned) gives a rich, spoonable result but is lower in protein and often separates. See the coconut yogurt recipe.
- Almond milk is mild but thin, and it usually needs a thickener. See how to make thick almond milk yogurt.
- Cashew milk blends into a creamy base with no straining. See the cashew yogurt recipe.
- Oat milk can set well if you cook the oat base with a thickener. See how to make oat milk yogurt that actually sets.
Whichever you pick, check the ingredient list. Many recipe writers recommend milks made from just the main ingredient and water, because added gums, oils, preservatives and sweeteners can interfere with fermentation. Results vary by brand, so expect some trial and error.
Starters
You need live bacterial cultures to turn plant milk into yogurt. Common options are:
- A spoonful of plain, unsweetened store-bought yogurt that lists live active cultures (dairy-free if you want the result to stay dairy-free).
- A powdered dairy-free yogurt starter, used according to the package.
- Probiotic capsules. Open them and use the powder. Some recipe writers advise choosing capsules without added prebiotic fibre or digestive enzymes, as these can lead to inconsistent results.
Once you have a successful batch, you can reserve a few tablespoons of it, before adding any flavoring, to start the next one. Starter strength can fade over successive batches, so many people restart with a fresh starter every so often.
Because plant milks contain little lactose, add about a teaspoon of plain sugar (or a little maple syrup) per quart or litre as food for the cultures, unless the milk is already sweetened. Avoid raw honey, which some sources say can interfere with the bacteria.
The basic method
- Clean everything. Wash jars, spoons and whisks well, and rinse them with boiling water.
- Heat the milk. If you are using a thickener, whisk it in and bring the milk to about 180°F (82°C) so it dissolves. Without a thickener, a gentle warm-up to the culturing temperature is enough for most store-bought milks.
- Cool to about 105-115°F (40-46°C). Adding starter to milk that is too hot can kill the cultures.
- Add the starter. Whisk a small amount of the warm milk into the starter first, then stir that back into the rest.
- Hold it warm. Keep the milk at roughly 100-115°F (38-46°C) for about 8-16 hours, depending on the milk and how tangy you like it. Don’t stir or jostle it while it cultures.
- Chill. Refrigerate for at least several hours. Plant yogurts often firm up noticeably in the fridge.
Sweeteners, vanilla and fruit are usually best stirred in after fermentation.
Making almond milk yogurt in an Instant Pot
The Instant Pot is a popular incubator because it holds a steady low temperature. A typical approach for almond milk:
- Pour the almond milk (and thickener, if using) into the inner pot. On many models, the Yogurt setting can be used to heat to about 180°F; otherwise use Sauté carefully, stirring so the milk doesn’t scorch.
- Remove the inner pot and let the milk cool to 105-115°F.
- Whisk in your starter and a little sugar.
- Return the pot, put the lid on, and run the Yogurt setting for roughly 8-16 hours. Shorter times give a milder flavor; longer times give a tangier one.
- Chill for at least 6-8 hours before eating.
How long should yogurt be in the Instant Pot? Plant-based recipes commonly range from about 8 to 16 hours. Start at the low end and taste. Thickened milks can set faster.
Is 120°F too hot for yogurt? For most starters, yes, it’s on the hot side. Many recipes keep the milk below about 115°F when the starter goes in and aim for roughly 105-115°F during incubation. Temperatures well above that can weaken or kill the cultures. Check your starter’s instructions, as some thermophilic cultures tolerate more heat.
What if my Instant Pot has no yogurt button? You can use another warm, stable spot instead: an oven with only the light on, a yogurt maker, a warm water bath in a cooler or stockpot, or a thermos-style insulated container. Check the temperature with a thermometer rather than trusting the setting.
Why is Instant Pot yogurt runny? Almond milk in particular has little protein, so without a thickener it will stay thin. See the thick almond yogurt guide. Other common reasons are milk with additives, inactive starter, milk that was too hot when the starter went in, or not chilling long enough.
Thickening options
- Agar-agar. A seaweed-based gelling agent that is vegan. Use small amounts, because too much makes the yogurt jelly-like. It has to be simmered with the milk to dissolve.
- Starches (arrowroot, tapioca, cornstarch). Heat them with the milk until it thickens slightly. They give creaminess rather than a firm set.
- Pectin. Used in some coconut yogurt recipes; it can clump if it isn’t blended in well.
- Gelatin. Works well but is not vegan or vegetarian.
- Straining. Strained yogurt is thicker and tangier. See how to make vegan Greek yogurt at home.
Troubleshooting
- Thin or runny: add a thickener next time, use a higher-protein milk like soy, or chill longer.
- Separated or curdled while warm: this is common and often looks worse than it is. Stir gently and chill before judging.
- Not tangy enough: culture a few hours longer, or use a fresher starter.
- Too sour: shorten the culture time.
- No change at all: the starter may have been inactive, the milk too hot or too cool, or the milk may contain preservatives.
Storage and safety
Refrigerate homemade plant yogurt in a clean, covered container. Many recipes say it keeps for roughly a week, though quality and shelf life depend on your hygiene and ingredients. Discard it if you see mold, pink or orange discoloration, or if it smells unpleasant in a way that isn’t just tangy. When in doubt, throw it out. Anyone who is pregnant, immunocompromised or has other health concerns should consider checking with a health professional before eating homemade fermented foods.
Where to go next
Pick the milk that suits you: soy, coconut, cashew or oat. If you’re avoiding lactose rather than all dairy, read our guide to lactose-free yogurt. And if you want to know how coconut yogurt compares nutritionally with dairy, see whether coconut yogurt is healthier than Greek yogurt.