Dairy-Free and Lactose-Free

How to Make Thick Almond Milk Yogurt at Home

Almond milk yogurt stays thin without help. Learn how agar, starch, gelatin and straining make it thick and creamy, with a step-by-step recipe and fixes.

On this page
  1. Why almond milk yogurt stays thin
  2. Start with the right almond milk
  3. Choosing a thickener
  4. Step-by-step recipe
  5. Straining and other tricks
  6. Fixing a thin batch
  7. Storage

Why almond milk yogurt stays thin

Dairy yogurt thickens because milk protein gels as the bacteria make acid. Almond milk contains very little protein, especially commercial versions, which are mostly water. The cultures will still ferment and sour the milk, but nothing is there to build a firm structure, so unthickened almond yogurt tends to stay pourable. The fix is to add a thickener, strain it, or both.

Start with the right almond milk

  • Homemade almond milk (almonds blended with water and strained) is the favorite of many recipe writers because it has no additives. Blanched almonds give a milder, less earthy flavor than skin-on almonds.
  • Store-bought almond milk can work, but additives and preservatives can interfere with fermentation. Look for the shortest ingredient list you can find, ideally unsweetened almonds and water, and expect results to vary by brand.
  • Don’t sweeten or flavor the milk first. Add sweetener and vanilla after fermentation.

Choosing a thickener

  • Agar-agar (vegan). A common guideline is about 1 heaped teaspoon of powder per 4 cups of milk, though amounts vary by brand and you may want to adjust on later batches. Too much gives a jelly-like texture. It must be simmered to dissolve and activate.
  • Arrowroot or tapioca starch. Roughly 1-2 tablespoons per quart is typical, heated with the milk until it slightly thickens. Starches give creaminess more than firmness.
  • Gelatin (not vegan or vegetarian). About 1 tablespoon of powdered gelatin per 4 cups is one commonly cited amount. It sets to a soft, creamy texture.
  • Pectin. Used in some nut-based yogurts, but it can clump if not blended in well.

Whichever you pick, treat the amount in a recipe as a starting point. Many cooks tweak it slightly up or down on the next batch to get the texture they like.

Step-by-step recipe

Makes about 4 cups.

Ingredients

  • 4 cups unsweetened almond milk, homemade or additive-free
  • Your thickener of choice (see above)
  • 1 teaspoon sugar, to feed the cultures (or a spoonful of pasteurized honey if you don’t need it vegan; avoid raw honey)
  • Starter: a dairy-free yogurt starter, a probiotic capsule’s powder, or a few tablespoons of plain live-culture non-dairy yogurt
  • Optional, after chilling: vanilla and maple syrup or honey to taste

Method

  1. Sanitize a jar, whisk and any utensils with boiling water.
  2. Whisk the thickener into the cold almond milk in a saucepan. Powders can float on top until they heat.
  3. Heat to about 180°F (82°C), stirring constantly, until the thickener has dissolved. Agar needs to simmer briefly.
  4. Cool to 105-115°F (40-46°C). Stir occasionally so it doesn’t form a skin or lumps. Adding starter while it’s hotter can kill the cultures.
  5. Add the sugar and starter. Mix a little warm milk into the starter first, then stir it back in.
  6. Ferment at roughly 105-115°F for about 8-16 hours. Shorter is milder; longer is tangier. An Instant Pot on the Yogurt setting, a yogurt maker, or a warm oven all work. See the Instant Pot section of our dairy-free yogurt guide for details.
  7. Chill for at least 6-8 hours. Straight from the incubator the yogurt is warm, and it may look curdled or separated; that is normal and usually improves once it’s cold and stirred.
  8. Stir in flavorings after chilling.

Straining and other tricks

Straining through cheesecloth or a nut milk bag for a few hours can make almond yogurt thicker and tangier, but because it has so little protein, the yogurt doesn’t behave like strained dairy yogurt, and the liquid that comes off can be substantial. A thickener usually works better. If you want a really thick result, consider blending in a spoonful of almond butter or soaked, blended cashews for extra body. A higher-protein base is another option: soy yogurt sets more reliably, and vegan Greek yogurt is made by culturing and then straining it.

Fixing a thin batch

  • Chill it longer; thickened yogurts often firm up considerably overnight.
  • Use a little more thickener next time, or switch thickener type.
  • If it is very runny, you can reheat it gently with a bit more thickener, cool it, and use it as a smoothie base or a pourable “drinking yogurt.” Don’t re-culture without fresh starter.
  • Check your starter and temperatures. A weak starter or milk that was too hot at inoculation can leave the milk sweet and thin.

Storage

Keep almond yogurt in a clean, covered container in the fridge. Recipes often suggest using it within about a week. Discard it if it smells unpleasant, or if you see mold or pink or orange spots. Save a few tablespoons of plain yogurt before flavoring for your next starter.

The complete guide to dairy-free and lactose-free

How to Make Dairy-Free Yogurt from Plant Milks
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →