The short answer
To make vegan Greek yogurt at home, ferment a high-protein plant milk with live cultures, then strain out some of the liquid so the yogurt thickens. Plain, unsweetened soy milk, ideally made from just soybeans and water, is the most common base because its protein helps it set. Culture it at roughly 108-110°F (42-43°C) for about 8-15 hours, then strain it in the fridge for several hours or longer.
What you need
- 4 cups (about 1 litre) plain, unsweetened soy milk. Many recipe writers prefer a milk with no gums, oils or added sugar. Brands differ, so you may need to try more than one. Some home cooks report success with milks containing small additives like ascorbic acid, but it’s less predictable.
- Starter: 2-4 tablespoons of plain vegan yogurt with live cultures, or a vegan yogurt starter, or opened probiotic capsules, following the package.
- A little sugar (about 1 teaspoon) if your soy milk is homemade or has no sugar at all, since the bacteria need something to feed on.
- A yogurt maker, Instant Pot, or another warm spot, plus a fine-mesh sieve or colander, cheesecloth or a nut milk bag, and a bowl.
Step by step
- Sanitize your jar, whisk and bowl with boiling water.
- Warm the milk gently if your method calls for it, to about 105-115°F (40-46°C). Shelf-stable soy milk is often used at room temperature or lightly warmed. Fresh homemade soy milk should be heated and cooled first.
- Add the starter. Whisk a few tablespoons of the warm milk into the starter first, then stir it back in.
- Ferment at about 108-110°F for roughly 8-15 hours until set and tangy. Don’t stir during this time. Taste after 8-10 hours, since longer times give a sourer yogurt.
- Chill the yogurt for a few hours so it firms up. Reserve a few tablespoons now if you want a starter for the next batch.
- Strain. Line a sieve with cheesecloth or a nut milk bag over a bowl, spoon in the yogurt, cover, and refrigerate.
Straining times and the leftover liquid
Recipes range from about 4 hours for a lightly thickened result to 24 hours or longer for something very dense. Check every few hours, because you can always strain longer but can’t put the liquid back. Longer straining also means a smaller yield: expect to lose a noticeable portion of the volume.
The liquid that drains off is mildly sour and can be used in smoothies, pancake or baking batters, or soups. Some people also use a few tablespoons to start the next batch.
Store the finished yogurt covered in the fridge. Recipes commonly say 7-10 days, but use your senses, and discard it if it smells off or shows mold.
Soy-free vegan Greek yogurt
If you’d rather avoid soy, you can follow the same culture-then-strain approach with other bases, though most will be softer and less protein-rich:
- Coconut milk or cream plus cashews, with a starch thickener, gives a rich, non-soy option. See our coconut yogurt recipe and our cashew yogurt recipe.
- Oat or almond milk with agar can be thickened, but they have little protein, so straining yields less. See how to make oat milk yogurt that actually sets.
- Some cooks blend silken tofu into soy milk before culturing to add protein and creaminess.
Tips and troubleshooting
- Too thin after straining: strain longer, or start with a firmer base.
- Chalky or grainy: whisk the strained yogurt smoothly, and avoid pushing hard on the cloth.
- Too sour: culture for fewer hours next time.
- Didn’t set: the starter may be weak, or the milk may have additives. See the dairy-free yogurt troubleshooting guide.
For a full soy yogurt recipe before straining, see our soy yogurt recipe. If you’re curious how plant yogurts compare to dairy Greek yogurt nutritionally, see coconut yogurt versus Greek yogurt.