Short answer
Draining yogurt usually takes anywhere from about 30 minutes to overnight, depending on how thick you want it. Longer draining removes more whey and gives a thicker result.
| Draining time | Typical result |
|---|---|
| 30 minutes to 2 hours | Slightly thicker, Greek-style yogurt |
| 2 to 4 hours | Richer, heavier and thicker |
| 6 to 12 hours, or overnight | Very thick, spreadable, like labneh or yogurt cheese |
These ranges are guides, not exact rules. Your starting yogurt, the cloth and the amount you strain all change the timing, so check the texture as you go.
What affects draining time
- How thick the yogurt was to begin with. A thin batch loses whey fast but may also slip through the cloth.
- Fat content. Whole-milk yogurt tends to give a creamier result, while low-fat and non-fat drain to a drier, more crumbly texture.
- Amount. A large quantity packed deep in a strainer drains more slowly than a thin layer.
- Cloth or filter. Fine cloth, coffee filters and paper towels drain slowly. Loose cheesecloth drains faster but may let some solids through.
- Temperature. Warm yogurt drains more quickly than cold yogurt. Draining warm is not a good idea for long periods, though, because of food safety.
- Pressure. Hanging a bag lets gravity do the work. Pressing or weighting speeds things up but can produce a grainier or drier result.
How to drain yogurt step by step
- Line a fine-mesh strainer, colander or specialty strainer with cheesecloth, a clean thin kitchen towel, a nut milk bag, a coffee filter or a paper towel.
- Set it over a deep bowl so the whey has somewhere to go.
- Spoon in the yogurt.
- Cover loosely and leave it to drip.
- Check after the first hour, then at intervals, and stop when it reaches the thickness you want.
- Scrape it into a clean container and whisk for about a minute if you want it smooth.
Counter or fridge?
For short draining of an hour or two, many cooks leave it on the counter. For longer draining, put the whole setup in the fridge. Yogurt left at room temperature for many hours is a food safety risk, and the general guideline is to avoid keeping perishable food out for more than two hours, or one hour in hot weather above 90°F (32°C). For more on that, see whether yogurt is safe after fermenting overnight or left out.
How to tell when it’s ready
- Greek-style: thick enough to hold a spoon-shaped dollop but still soft and creamy.
- Thicker, strained: stays in a mound and looks like soft sour cream.
- Labneh or yogurt cheese: spreadable like cream cheese. It holds its shape when you scoop and may be rolled into balls once chilled.
The weight of the whey collected also gives a clue. If you drain a quart of yogurt for a few hours and gather about a cup of whey, you will have a noticeably thicker product, but the exact amounts vary by batch.
If you drained too long
If the yogurt looks dry or crumbly, like cottage cheese, whisk in a spoonful or two of the drained whey, or a splash of milk, until it loosens. Next time, check earlier. Our guide to homemade yogurt problems explains why Greek-style yogurt sometimes looks grainy.
If your yogurt is runny because it never set properly, straining may not rescue it, since very thin yogurt can pass through the cloth. See why homemade yogurt didn’t thicken.
What to do with the whey
Do not feel you have to throw it away. Whey can go into smoothies, soups, bread or pancake batter in place of some water. Keep it in the fridge and use it within a few days. For the nutrition side of what leaves with the whey, see does straining whey from yogurt remove protein.
Draining also tends to concentrate tang, so very long straining of an already sour batch can taste sharp. See why yogurt tastes too sour.