Dairy-Free and Lactose-Free

Is coconut yogurt healthier than Greek yogurt?

For most people Greek yogurt offers more protein and calcium with less saturated fat than coconut yogurt. See how they compare and when coconut is the better pick.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Protein
  3. Fat and calories
  4. Calcium, vitamin B12 and fortification
  5. Sugar and carbohydrates
  6. Probiotics
  7. What about homemade coconut yogurt?
  8. Which should you choose?

The short answer

For most people, plain Greek yogurt is the more nutritious choice. It typically provides much more protein and, naturally, more calcium, with less saturated fat than coconut yogurt. Coconut yogurt is best thought of as a dairy-free or vegan alternative rather than a nutritional upgrade. If you avoid dairy, it can still be a perfectly reasonable option, particularly if you pick a plain, fortified product. This is general information, not personal medical advice, and a dietitian can help if you have specific health goals.

Protein

This is the biggest gap. Greek yogurt is strained, which concentrates its milk protein, so a typical single serving of plain Greek yogurt provides around 15 grams of protein or more, though it varies by brand and fat level. Coconut yogurt usually contains very little protein, often only a gram or two per serving, since coconut itself is low in protein. If protein matters to you, for fullness or muscle maintenance, this favors Greek yogurt, or a plant-based option made from soy, which tends to have more protein than coconut.

Fat and calories

Coconut is naturally high in fat, and most of that fat is saturated. Coconut yogurts are therefore often higher in calories, total fat and saturated fat than plain nonfat or low-fat Greek yogurt, and can be higher than full-fat Greek yogurt too, depending on the brand. A dietitian comparing a leading coconut yogurt to full-cream Greek yogurt found the coconut version had noticeably more fat and saturated fat and substantially less protein. High saturated fat intake can raise LDL cholesterol in some people, so it’s worth checking labels if you are watching that.

Calcium, vitamin B12 and fortification

Dairy yogurt naturally supplies calcium and also vitamin B12 and potassium. Coconut yogurt doesn’t naturally contain much calcium, and many early products had none. Some brands now add calcium and sometimes vitamin D or B12, so look for “fortified” on the label, and compare the numbers.

Sugar and carbohydrates

Coconut yogurts are often lower in carbohydrates and total sugar than dairy yogurt, which may be why they have a health halo. But the sugar in plain dairy yogurt is naturally occurring lactose, not added sugar. Flavored products of either type can contain a lot of added sugar, so choose plain and add your own fruit.

Probiotics

Both can contain live cultures, but it depends on the brand. Coconut doesn’t ferment on its own, so manufacturers add cultures, and not every product keeps them alive after processing. Look for “live and active cultures” on the label for either type. Some dairy yogurts are heat-treated after fermentation, which kills the cultures too.

What about homemade coconut yogurt?

Homemade versions give you control over ingredients, but they aren’t fortified, and they will generally be low in protein. If you make homemade coconut yogurt, consider pairing it with other foods that supply calcium and protein. For a higher-protein plant-based option, try our soy yogurt recipe or vegan Greek yogurt.

Which should you choose?

  • Choose Greek yogurt if you eat dairy and want more protein, calcium and fullness with less saturated fat.
  • Choose coconut yogurt if you are vegan, have a milk allergy or are dairy-free for other reasons. Pick plain, with calcium added and live cultures, and watch portion size, as some containers hold more than one serving.
  • Choose lactose-free dairy yogurt if lactose is your only issue; see our lactose-free yogurt guide.

Whichever you choose, the healthiest option is usually the plain version that you’ll actually eat, topped with fruit or nuts rather than sugar.

The complete guide to dairy-free and lactose-free

How to Make Dairy-Free Yogurt from Plant Milks
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →