Greek and Strained Yogurt

How to Strain Greek Yogurt Without Cheesecloth: 5 Easy Substitutes

No cheesecloth? Strain homemade Greek yogurt with coffee filters, a cotton towel, a nut milk bag, paper towels or a fine sieve. Tips for each method.

On this page
  1. What cheesecloth actually does
  2. 1. Coffee filters
  3. 2. A clean cotton tea towel or flour-sack towel
  4. 3. A nut milk bag (or jelly bag)
  5. 4. Paper towels
  6. 5. A fine-mesh sieve on its own
  7. DIY strainer from two plastic containers
  8. General tips
  9. Getting the yogurt out

What cheesecloth actually does

Cheesecloth lets the thin, watery whey drain through while holding back the yogurt solids. Anything that does the same job can replace it: a fine weave, clean, and not so tight that it clogs. Here are five options, followed by a simple do-it-yourself strainer.

1. Coffee filters

A paper coffee filter is the easiest swap. Set a basket-style filter inside a fine-mesh sieve or a colander, set that over a bowl, and spoon in the yogurt.

  • Pros: Cheap, fine enough to hold back nearly everything, no washing.
  • Cons: Drains more slowly than cloth and can clog. You may need to use several filters for a large batch, or stir gently now and then.
  • Tip: Use unbleached filters if you prefer, and scrape the yogurt off with a spatula, since it can cling to the paper.

2. A clean cotton tea towel or flour-sack towel

A thin, smooth, lint-free cotton towel works much like cheesecloth. Line a sieve with it, leave the corners hanging over the sides, add the yogurt, then gather the corners to make a bundle if you want to hang it.

  • Pros: Reusable, and great for big batches.
  • Cons: Thick or fuzzy towels drain slowly and leave lint. Scented detergent or fabric softener can leave a smell.
  • Tip: Use a towel only for food and wash it without fabric softener. Muslin and fine, soft cotton work well too.

3. A nut milk bag (or jelly bag)

These fine-mesh bags are made for straining. Spoon the yogurt in, hang the bag over a bowl or from a cupboard handle in the refrigerator, and let it drip.

  • Pros: Sturdy and reusable, and easy to squeeze or hang.
  • Cons: Needs a spare item you may not own, and the seams can trap yogurt, so rinse right away.

4. Paper towels

In a pinch, a few sheets of sturdy paper towel in a sieve will drain yogurt.

  • Pros: Everyone has them.
  • Cons: They can tear when wet and clog easily, and some leave a papery taste. Use plain white towels, and double up the layers.
  • Tip: This is best for small amounts and shorter straining times.

5. A fine-mesh sieve on its own

A very fine sieve or tea strainer can do the job without any liner, particularly if the yogurt is already fairly thick. Place it over a bowl and spoon the yogurt in.

  • Pros: Nothing extra to buy.
  • Cons: Yogurt may squeeze through the mesh, especially if it is thin or the mesh is coarse. Use a fine mesh.

DIY strainer from two plastic containers

One simple homemade setup uses two plastic containers, one smaller than the other. Poke plenty of holes in the bottom of the smaller one with an awl, fork or the tip of a paring knife, then set it inside the larger container with room to spare. Line the smaller container with a basket coffee filter, add the yogurt, and put the whole thing in the refrigerator for an hour or two. Whey collects in the bigger container below. Wash and sanitize both containers before using them for food.

General tips

Getting the yogurt out

When it has reached the thickness you want, scrape the yogurt from the liner with a spatula. With a coffee filter, you can grab the center of the filter from the bottom and squeeze the last of the yogurt out. For cloth, turn the bundle over a bowl and scrape. Store the finished yogurt covered in the refrigerator.

The complete guide to greek and strained yogurt

How to Make Thick Greek Yogurt at Home
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →