What you need
Coconut yogurt can be made with as little as two ingredients:
- Full-fat canned coconut milk or coconut cream, about two 13.5-14 oz (400 ml) cans. Look for a can that lists only coconut and water, as gums and preservatives can interfere with the cultures. Brands vary a lot, so if one doesn’t work, try another.
- A live-culture starter: 2-3 opened probiotic capsules (powder only), a few tablespoons of plain live-culture coconut yogurt, or a dairy-free yogurt starter used per its instructions.
- Optional: 1 teaspoon of sugar or 1 tablespoon of maple syrup to feed the cultures, and a thickener (see below).
You’ll also need a clean glass jar or bowl, a non-metal spoon, and a warm place to ferment, such as a yogurt maker, an oven with only the light on, or a warm water bath.
Method
- Sanitize. Rinse the jar and spoon with boiling water and let them cool.
- Prepare the coconut. Shake the cans and pour the contents into the jar, or chill the cans overnight and scoop out just the thick cream on top if you want a richer, thicker yogurt. Save the watery liquid for smoothies.
- Warm gently if you like. Some recipes simply stir the starter into room-temperature coconut milk. Others warm the milk to around 100-110°F (38-43°C) first. If you heat the milk, for example with a thickener, make sure it has cooled below about 115°F (46°C) before adding the starter.
- Add the starter and sweetener. Stir well.
- Ferment. Cover loosely with a cloth or a loose lid and keep warm for about 12-48 hours, depending on your method and how tangy you want it. Recipes that use probiotic capsules at lower temperatures tend to need the longer end. Taste after about 12-24 hours.
- Chill. Stir, cover tightly, and refrigerate for at least 4-6 hours or overnight. Coconut yogurt thickens considerably as the coconut fat firms up in the cold.
One test-kitchen style recipe (using coconut flakes blended into a fresh milk) adds 2 teaspoons of pectin powder, heats to 60°C, cools to 43°C, then ferments in a 46°C water bath for 12-24 hours. It’s a good option if you want to make your own coconut milk rather than use canned.
Using coconut cream for a thicker yogurt
A coconut cream yogurt uses only the solid cream layer or a canned coconut cream. It sets thicker and richer but is also heavier, so many people thin it with a little of the reserved coconut water or a splash of plain coconut milk. Because there is less liquid, it tends to feel closer to Greek-style yogurt.
Thickener options
Coconut yogurt often turns out looser than people expect. If you’d like extra body, whisk about 1 tablespoon of tapioca starch or arrowroot, or a small amount of agar-agar, into the coconut milk and heat gently until it thickens, then cool below 115°F before adding the starter. Pectin is another choice, but it can clump if not blended well. For other thickening methods and how they compare, see our guide to dairy-free yogurt.
Troubleshooting
- Watery layer on top: normal for coconut. Stir it back in, or pour it off. Chilling usually helps.
- Not tangy or not changing: the starter may be weak, or the room was too cool. Keep it warmer and give it longer.
- Too sour: shorten the ferment next time.
- Grainy or lumpy: blend with an immersion blender or whisk well before chilling. Cold cream can be lumpy if it wasn’t mixed smoothly.
- Off smell, mold, or pink/orange spots: discard the batch.
Storage
Keep it refrigerated in a clean, airtight container. Many recipes say it lasts up to about a week. Reserve a couple of tablespoons of plain yogurt before adding flavorings if you want to use it as a starter for the next batch, but note that starters can lose vigor after several rounds.
Common questions
Can I substitute coconut yogurt for Greek yogurt? Often yes in baking, dips and bowls, though coconut yogurt is usually looser, milder and has far less protein. You may need to strain it or reduce other liquids. For a nutritional comparison, see whether coconut yogurt is healthier than Greek yogurt. If you want something closer to Greek, try vegan Greek yogurt.
What type of yogurt is vegan? Yogurts made from plant milks such as soy, coconut, almond, cashew or oat, with no milk, gelatin or other animal-derived ingredients. Always check the label, since some products add animal-derived thickeners or colors.
What can replace coconut milk in a recipe? Other full-fat plant milks or creams, such as cashew cream, can work depending on the dish. See our cashew yogurt recipe for a coconut-free base.
Why might coconut yogurt upset my stomach? Coconut is high in fat, and some people find rich or fermented foods hard to digest. Added sugars, gums or sugar alcohols in some store-bought products can also cause problems. If symptoms persist, talk to a doctor or dietitian.
What happened to coconut yogurt? Availability of specific brands changes over time, and some have been reformulated or discontinued. Making your own is a reliable alternative.
For milk-by-milk comparisons and general technique, return to our dairy-free yogurt guide.