Why oat milk yogurt often doesn’t set
Oat milk is low in the type of protein that gels during fermentation, so, like almond milk, it won’t turn firm just because bacteria have soured it. Many commercial oat milks are also treated with enzymes that break the oat starch down into sugars, so they pour smoothly. That can be useful for feeding cultures but doesn’t help with thickness. The practical solution is to give the oat milk something to set with, usually a thickener that is cooked into the milk before culturing.
Homemade or carton oat milk?
You can use either. Homemade oat milk, made from rolled oats and water, is cheap and has no additives, and the oat starch in it can contribute some body when heated. Carton oat milk is convenient, but gums, oils, preservatives and sweeteners can interfere with the cultures, and results vary a lot between brands. If you use carton milk, choose the plainest one you can find, and expect to experiment.
Ingredients
For about 3 cups:
- 1/2 cup rolled oats (use certified gluten-free oats if you need to avoid gluten)
- 3 cups water
- Thickener: agar-agar powder is the usual vegan choice. Recipes range from roughly 1 to 1 1/2 teaspoons of powder for this quantity. Start at the lower end, since too much makes the yogurt jelly-like. If you don’t need it vegan, about 2 teaspoons of gelatin is an alternative.
- Starter: a pinch of dairy-free yogurt starter or probiotic powder (follow the package), or 2-4 tablespoons of plain vegan yogurt with live cultures.
- Optional: 1 teaspoon sugar or 1-2 tablespoons maple syrup to feed the cultures, a pinch of salt, and vanilla added after fermentation.
Step by step
- Sanitize jars, a pot, whisk and spoons by washing them well and rinsing with boiling water.
- Make the oat milk. Blend the oats with the water for only about 30 seconds. Over-blending, or blending with warm water, tends to make oat milk slimy.
- Strain through a nut milk bag, cheesecloth or fine sieve. Squeeze gently.
- Thicken. Whisk the agar (and any sugar or salt) into the strained oat milk in a saucepan. Bring to a simmer over medium heat, stirring constantly, until the agar is dissolved and the milk thickens slightly. Agar generally needs to simmer for a couple of minutes to dissolve properly.
- Cool to about 100-110°F (38-43°C). Don’t add starter while it’s hot, or you will kill the cultures. Stir occasionally while it cools so the agar doesn’t form lumps.
- Add the starter. Whisk it in until smooth.
- Ferment. Pour into clean jars, and keep at roughly 100-110°F for about 8-24 hours. An Instant Pot on the Yogurt setting, a yogurt maker or a warm oven with the light on all work. Longer fermentation gives a tangier yogurt. Don’t stir while it cultures.
- Chill for at least 3-6 hours or overnight, until firm and cold. Oat yogurt generally thickens as it cools.
Tips for a firmer set
- Cook the thickener fully before culturing, and use a thermometer so the starter isn’t added too hot.
- If you have the option, use a bit less water per portion of oats, which makes a richer base, though it can also make the milk gluey.
- A spoonful of coconut cream stirred into the base gives a creamier, thicker result, and some cooks make a richer “Greek-style” version this way. See our coconut yogurt recipe.
- Straining gives a thicker result but works less well than with soy, because oat yogurt has little protein. For a Greek-style yogurt, soy is the more dependable base.
- For more on how thickeners compare, see our dairy-free yogurt guide and the thickening section of how to make thick almond milk yogurt.
Troubleshooting
- Runny: use a little more agar next time, chill longer, or check that your starter was alive and the milk wasn’t too hot when you added it.
- Slimy: blend for less time and use cold water.
- Too firm or jelly-like: reduce the agar.
- Not tangy: extend fermentation or use fresher starter.
- Too sour: ferment for fewer hours.
- Mold, pink or orange spots, or an unpleasant smell: throw it out.
Gluten note and storage
Oats are often processed alongside wheat, so people with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity should choose certified gluten-free oats and starters. Store the yogurt in the fridge in a covered container, and use it within about a week. Reserve a few tablespoons of plain yogurt before flavoring if you’d like to use it as a starter for your next batch.