Greek and Strained Yogurt

Skyr, Quark and Greek Yogurt: How They Differ and How to Make Each

Skyr, quark and Greek yogurt are all thick and high in protein but made differently. Compare taste, texture and nutrition, plus home methods for each.

On this page
  1. Quick comparison
  2. What is skyr?
  3. What is quark?
  4. Greek yogurt, for contrast
  5. Nutrition and which to choose
  6. Can you swap them?
  7. How to make each at home

Quick comparison

Skyr, quark and Greek yogurt are all thick, spoonable, protein-rich cultured dairy foods, which is why they get confused. The differences come down to how they are made and what they are classified as.

Greek yogurt Skyr Quark
Origin Eastern Mediterranean, popular worldwide Iceland Germany and central Europe
What it is Strained yogurt Traditionally a strained fresh cheese, eaten like yogurt Fresh cheese
Typical milk Whole, low-fat or nonfat Traditionally skim Often low-fat or skim, varies
Culture Yogurt cultures, warm incubation Yogurt-type cultures plus a little rennet traditionally Mesophilic (cooler) culture, often with a little rennet
Texture Thick, creamy Very dense, smooth Soft, smooth, spreadable
Flavor Tangy Mild, slightly sour Mild, fresh, lightly tangy

Exact textures and flavors vary by brand and recipe, so use this as a guide.

What is skyr?

Skyr is an Icelandic dairy product with a history going back many centuries. It is technically considered a fresh cheese, although it is sold and eaten like yogurt. Traditional skyr starts from skim milk, which is cultured, then strained, so a lot of whey is drained off. The result is dense and mild, and many people find it less tart than Greek yogurt. Many commercial skyrs are made with yogurt-style cultures, and not all follow the traditional recipe.

What is quark?

Quark is a soft fresh cheese common in Germany and central and eastern Europe. It is made by souring milk with a mesophilic culture, often with a small amount of rennet, then draining the curds. It is smoother and softer than cottage cheese and more spreadable than yogurt, with a mild, fresh flavor.

What is the English version of quark? There isn’t a single exact equivalent. It’s often described as something between yogurt, fromage frais and soft cream cheese. In English-speaking countries it is increasingly sold under its own name. Strained plain yogurt is the closest widely available substitute.

Greek yogurt, for contrast

Greek yogurt is regular yogurt with the whey strained off. Unlike skyr and quark, it is made with the same warm-incubated cultures as ordinary yogurt and is not usually considered a cheese. It is tangier and typically a little looser than skyr. Our guide to making thick Greek yogurt at home walks through the full method.

Nutrition and which to choose

All three are good sources of protein and calcium, and all three tend to be higher in protein than unstrained yogurt. Skyr is often a bit higher in protein than Greek yogurt and is traditionally made from skim milk, so it tends to be lower in fat. But brands differ a lot, and fat level and added sugar matter more than the name on the tub. Compare labels, choose plain versions, and add your own fruit.

Is skyr the healthiest yogurt? It’s a good option, but no single yogurt is best for everyone. Is it okay to eat skyr every day? For most people eating dairy, a daily portion of plain skyr, Greek yogurt or quark can fit into a balanced diet. If you have a health condition or a dairy allergy or intolerance, ask a health professional. The time of day doesn’t matter much. Eat it whenever it suits you.

Can you swap them?

Often, with small tweaks:

  • Greek yogurt for skyr: Usually fine. Greek yogurt may be a bit tangier and slightly looser.
  • Skyr for Greek yogurt: Fine. Thin it with a splash of milk or water if you want a looser texture.
  • Greek yogurt for quark: Can you use fat-free Greek yogurt instead of quark? In most cold dishes, dips and baking, yes. Fat-free Greek yogurt is tangier and can be grainier or split when heated, so for cooking use a fuller-fat version or whisk it smooth first.

For more on swapping thick yogurt into recipes, see Can Greek yogurt be substituted for whole milk yogurt?

How to make each at home

Greek yogurt

Culture warm milk with a yogurt starter, then strain the set yogurt in a cloth-lined strainer in the refrigerator for several hours.

Skyr-style

You can get close to skyr at home. Heat skim milk to about 180°F (82°C), cool to about 110°F (43°C), then add a spoonful of live-culture yogurt. Traditional recipes also add a few drops of liquid rennet. Strengths vary, so follow the instructions on your rennet. Incubate until set, then strain for longer than you would for Greek yogurt, until very thick. Without rennet, heavily strained skim-milk yogurt is a reasonable approximation.

Quark

Warm milk to roughly room temperature or just above (around 72-77°F, or 22-25°C). Stir in a mesophilic starter, such as cultured buttermilk or a packaged mesophilic culture, plus a tiny amount of rennet. Leave it covered at room temperature, typically 12 to 24 hours, until it has set into a soft curd. Ladle the curd into a cloth-lined strainer and drain until it has the thickness you want, then whisk it smooth. Rennet and culture instructions vary, so follow your package.

All three methods give you whey as a by-product, with plenty of ways to use it. See what to do with leftover whey.

The complete guide to greek and strained yogurt

How to Make Thick Greek Yogurt at Home
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →