Cheese and Cultured Dairy

How to Make Cultured Butter with Yogurt

Make cultured butter at home by culturing cream with a spoonful of live yogurt, then churning and washing it. Steps, tips and storage notes.

On this page
  1. What yogurt does in cultured butter
  2. What you need
  3. Step by step
  4. Using the buttermilk
  5. Making butter from curd or yogurt itself
  6. Traditional churning
  7. Is it good for you?
  8. Storage

What yogurt does in cultured butter

Cultured butter is made from cream that has been soured with live bacteria before it is churned. The fermentation adds a gentle tang and a more complex, nutty flavor than butter from fresh “sweet” cream.

Yogurt is not the thing you churn here. It is the starter. A spoonful of plain yogurt with live cultures introduces the bacteria that culture the cream. Greek yogurt works, and so does regular plain yogurt or cultured buttermilk, as long as the label shows live and active cultures.

What you need

  • 2 cups (about 500 ml) heavy cream or whipping cream, ideally with a fat content around 35 to 40 percent
  • 2 tablespoons plain yogurt with live cultures per 2 cups of cream, or 1 to 2 tablespoons per cup
  • a clean glass jar or bowl
  • a stand mixer, hand mixer, food processor or a jar for shaking
  • ice-cold water
  • salt (optional)
  • a fine sieve or clean cloth

Pasteurized cream is the safest and most predictable choice. Ultra-pasteurized cream can still be cultured and churned, though results are sometimes less predictable. Avoid raw milk or cream unless you understand the safety considerations and have a trusted, tested source.

Step by step

  1. Culture. Stir the yogurt into the cream in a clean jar. Cover loosely with a cloth or coffee filter and leave it at a comfortable room temperature, roughly 70 to 75°F (21 to 24°C), for 12 to 24 hours. It should thicken slightly and smell pleasantly tangy.
  2. Chill. Refrigerate the cultured cream for several hours or overnight. Cold cream churns more cleanly.
  3. Churn. Whip the cream in a mixer or food processor. It will pass through whipped cream, turn grainy, and then suddenly separate into butter grains and thin buttermilk. Keep going for a few moments after that.
  4. Drain. Pour off the buttermilk and keep it.
  5. Wash. Rinse the butter in ice-cold water, pressing it with a spatula, and change the water until it runs mostly clear. Washing out the buttermilk matters because leftover buttermilk shortens the butter’s life.
  6. Salt and shape. Knead in a pinch of salt if you want salted butter. Shape it, wrap it tightly and refrigerate.

Two cups of cream gives a modest amount of butter, around a cup or a little less, plus buttermilk. Exact yields depend on the fat content of the cream.

Using the buttermilk

The buttermilk from cultured cream is real cultured buttermilk. Use it in pancakes, biscuits, soda bread or as a starter for crème fraîche or homemade sour cream.

Making butter from curd or yogurt itself

In some households, particularly in South Asia, butter is made by churning curd (dahi) that has had its cream skimmed or collected. This is different from the method above. Plain yogurt made from low-fat milk has very little fat to separate, so the yield is small. How much butter you get depends on the fat in the milk you started with, so no single figure applies. If you want reliable butter, start with cream.

Traditional churning

Traditional home churning, such as the Amish approach, generally involves letting cream sit and sour at room temperature, then churning it in a jar, crock or hand-cranked churn until the butter separates, and working and washing it. The principles are the same as above. The details vary from household to household.

Is it good for you?

Yogurt butter is still butter, which means it is mostly fat and is a rich food. The bacterial culture does not make it a probiotic food in any reliable way, particularly once the butter has been washed. Treat it like regular butter in your diet, and talk to a health professional if you have specific dietary needs.

Storage

Cultured butter keeps best wrapped tightly and refrigerated, and it can be frozen. For specifics, see how long homemade cultured butter lasts.

The complete guide to cheese and cultured dairy

How to Make Cheese from Yogurt at Home
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →