Cheese and Cultured Dairy

Buttermilk, Sour Cream and Lassi vs Yogurt: What's the Difference?

Is buttermilk yogurt? Is Greek yogurt sour cream? Is lassi yogurt? Plain answers on how these cultured dairy foods differ and when to swap them.

On this page
  1. Quick answers
  2. Is buttermilk yogurt?
  3. Is Greek yogurt sour cream?
  4. Is lassi yogurt?
  5. Making your own
  6. Spoilage signs

Quick answers

Question Short answer
Is buttermilk yogurt? No. They are both cultured, but buttermilk is a thin drink and yogurt is a set, thick product.
Is Greek yogurt sour cream? No. Sour cream is cultured cream and much higher in fat. Greek yogurt is strained cultured milk.
Is lassi yogurt? Not exactly. Lassi is a drink made from yogurt, thinned with water or milk and flavored.

Is buttermilk yogurt?

No, though they are related. Both are soured by bacteria that produce lactic acid.

  • Cultured buttermilk (the type sold in most stores) is milk fermented with lactic acid bacteria. It is thin, tangy and pourable.
  • Traditional buttermilk is the liquid left over after churning cream into butter. Where it is still made, it can be thin and mildly sour, especially if the cream was cultured first.
  • Yogurt is milk fermented with specific bacteria at a warm temperature until it sets into a gel.

In Middle Eastern and South Asian cooking, “buttermilk” and related words (such as laban, chaas or ayran) often refer to thinned, salted yogurt drinks. Usage varies by region, so “is buttermilk the same as laban?” has no single answer.

Buttermilk can be a decent substitute for yogurt in baking if you thin the recipe accordingly, and thinned yogurt can substitute for buttermilk. A common approach is to thin plain yogurt with a little milk until it is pourable. Results won’t be identical but are usually close.

Cultured buttermilk is a nice by-product of homemade cultured butter and can be used as a starter for crème fraîche.

Is Greek yogurt sour cream?

No. Sour cream is made by culturing cream, so it has a high fat content and a rich, smooth feel. Greek yogurt is made from cultured milk that has been strained, so it is thick and tangy but usually has far less fat unless you buy a full-fat version.

They are close enough that Greek yogurt is a popular stand-in for sour cream in dips, toppings and some baking. Expect a tangier, slightly lighter result. Greek yogurt can curdle in hot sauces, so stir it in off the heat or use full-fat yogurt.

If plain Greek yogurt tastes like sour cream to you, that makes sense: both are tangy, thick and creamy. A very sour yogurt is sometimes just an older one, so check the date and smell.

To make real sour cream at home, see how to make sour cream with cream and cultures.

Is lassi yogurt?

Lassi is a yogurt-based drink from South Asia. It is made by blending yogurt with water or milk, and then adding either salt and spices (a salty lassi) or sugar and fruit (such as mango). It tastes tangy, cool and creamy, a bit like a thin, sweet or savory yogurt.

  • Lassi vs buttermilk: both are thin and tangy. Lassi is usually richer because it is made from whole yogurt. Chaas, a South Asian buttermilk drink, is lighter and thinner.
  • Lassi vs kefir: not the same. Kefir is fermented from milk using kefir grains or a kefir starter, while lassi is blended from yogurt and isn’t fermented further. See milk kefir grains.
  • Is lassi healthy? It depends on what goes in it. A plain or lightly salted lassi is mostly yogurt and water. A sweet lassi can have a lot of added sugar.

Making your own

  • For buttermilk-style cultured dairy, thinned yogurt or a spoonful of cultured buttermilk with milk both work.
  • For sour cream, culture cream with a little buttermilk or yogurt.
  • For lassi, blend plain yogurt with cold water or milk and flavor to taste.

If you’d like to go beyond drinks and turn yogurt into cheese, see our overview of making cheese from yogurt.

Spoilage signs

Any of these dairy products should be discarded if they develop mold, a strong rotten or yeasty smell, an unusual color, or an unexpectedly bubbly or bloated container. A little separation of whey on yogurt or sour cream is normal, and you can stir it back in.

The complete guide to cheese and cultured dairy

How to Make Cheese from Yogurt at Home
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →