Cheese and Cultured Dairy

Homemade Cream Cheese from Greek Yogurt

Make a thick, tangy cream cheese-style spread by straining Greek yogurt overnight. Includes timing, salt, flavors, storage and how it compares.

On this page
  1. What you get
  2. What you need
  3. Step by step
  4. Texture by draining time
  5. Flavor ideas
  6. Cream cheese vs yogurt
  7. Storage and whey
  8. Troubleshooting

What you get

Straining Greek yogurt removes most of its remaining whey and leaves a dense, spreadable cheese. It is tangier and a little softer than commercial cream cheese, and it has more of a yogurt flavor, but it works well on bagels and toast, in dips and as a base for frostings and fillings.

Strictly speaking this is yogurt cheese, not cream cheese. Commercial cream cheese is made from cream or a cream and milk mix, soured with lactic acid or cultures, and usually finished with stabilizers. The yogurt version starts from an already cultured product, so the flavor and nutrition profile are different.

What you need

Step by step

  1. Stir the salt and any lemon juice into the yogurt until smooth.
  2. Line the sieve with the cloth or paper towel and set it over the bowl. Make sure the bottom of the sieve stays above the whey.
  3. Spoon in the yogurt and fold the cloth over the top.
  4. For a firmer result, place a small plate and a light weight on top.
  5. Refrigerate for 8 to 24 hours. Longer draining makes it thicker.
  6. Scrape the cheese into a clean container and chill.

Most people find that overnight gives a spreadable cheese, while a day or two gives something very thick that can be shaped. Because Greek yogurt has already been strained, it drains less than regular yogurt, so don’t expect a large volume of whey.

Texture by draining time

Time in fridge Result
A few hours Very thick yogurt, good for dips
8 to 12 hours Soft, spreadable cream cheese texture
24 hours Firm, rich spread
2 days or more Dense and sliceable, can be rolled into balls

Flavor ideas

  • Savory: chives, dill, garlic, black pepper, or a spoonful of za’atar.
  • Sweet: honey, maple syrup, or jam. This is a useful fix if you used non-fat or 2% yogurt and want to soften the tang.
  • Bagel spread: fold in finely chopped scallions or herbs after straining.

Cream cheese vs yogurt

Cream cheese Yogurt cheese
Made from Cream or milk and cream, soured with cultures or acid Cultured milk, strained
Flavor Mild, rich and buttery Tangier, more yogurt-like
Fat Much higher Depends on the yogurt you start with
Protein Lower Generally higher in strained yogurt
Probiotics Usually not a feature, and many are not marketed as probiotic Present only if the yogurt had live cultures
Heat stability Holds up well in baking Can loosen or separate under heat

Exact numbers vary by brand and fat level, so check the labels for what you buy. If you are thinking about swapping one for the other in a recipe, see our guide to substituting Greek yogurt for cream cheese.

Storage and whey

Keep the cheese in an airtight container in the fridge. About a week is a sensible limit for a homemade fresh product. Throw it out if it smells off or shows mold.

The whey doesn’t need to be wasted. It can replace buttermilk or water in bread, pancakes and muffins, or go into smoothies. Salted whey is less useful in sweet baking, so you may want to skip salt in the yogurt if you plan to reuse the whey.

Troubleshooting

  • Too tangy: use a milder, whole-milk yogurt or stir in a little honey.
  • Too soft: drain longer or add a light weight.
  • Dry or crumbly: you drained it too long. Stir in a spoonful of fresh yogurt or a splash of milk.
  • Breaks down when mixed: avoid beating it vigorously. Fold it in gently.

For a saltier, more traditional Middle Eastern version with olive oil, see how to make labneh. For other ways to turn yogurt into cheese, read the overview on making cheese from yogurt.

The complete guide to cheese and cultured dairy

How to Make Cheese from Yogurt at Home
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →