What whey ricotta is
Ricotta means “recooked.” The traditional version is made by heating the whey left over from making cheese until the small amount of remaining protein in the whey clumps into soft, fine curds. These are skimmed or strained out and drained.
Today many “ricotta” recipes use whole milk instead of whey, but you can make a real whey ricotta at home if you have enough whey to work with.
Sweet whey vs yogurt whey
Not all whey behaves the same.
- Sweet whey comes from cheeses made with rennet, such as mozzarella or many hard cheeses. It still holds a modest amount of whey protein, which is what forms ricotta curds when heated.
- Acid whey is the liquid drained from yogurt, labneh or acid-set cheeses like paneer. It is more acidic and generally gives a small yield on its own. Its proteins don’t recover well from acid whey, and the whey often looks thin and clear already.
For that reason, many home cooks improve results with yogurt or acid whey by adding some milk. Milk provides extra protein and fat so there are enough solids to form curds.
Method from cheese whey
You need
- fresh whey from rennet-based cheesemaking, ideally used the same day (a few quarts or liters gives a small amount of ricotta)
- salt
- a pot, thermometer, slotted spoon or ladle, and a cloth-lined strainer
- a splash of vinegar or lemon juice, only if the curds don’t form on their own
Steps
- Pour the fresh whey into a pot and warm it slowly, stirring now and then so it doesn’t stick.
- Raise the temperature gradually to roughly 175 to 195°F (80 to 90°C). Fine white flecks will begin to appear and rise.
- If very little forms, add a small amount of vinegar or lemon juice, stir once, then stop stirring.
- Turn off the heat and let it sit undisturbed for 10 to 20 minutes while the curds gather.
- Ladle the curds into a cloth-lined strainer and let them drain for 10 to 30 minutes, depending on how moist you want them.
- Season with a little salt.
Yield is small. A large pot of whey can produce just a modest bowl of ricotta, and it can be fragile and light.
Method from yogurt whey (with added milk)
- Combine the yogurt whey with a good amount of whole milk. A common starting point is to add roughly one part milk for every two to four parts whey, and you can use more milk for a creamier result.
- Heat gently, stirring occasionally, to about 185 to 195°F (85 to 90°C).
- The acid in the whey will often curdle the milk without further help. If it doesn’t, add a splash of vinegar or lemon juice.
- Rest the pot for 10 minutes, then strain through cloth.
The result is closer to a simple acid-set cheese, similar to paneer or farmer’s cheese, than traditional ricotta, but it is soft and good in cooking. For ideas about where yogurt whey comes from, see how to make cheese from yogurt.
Troubleshooting
- No curds form. The whey may be too old, too thin or have too little protein. Add some milk or a splash more acid.
- Tiny, fine curds that slip through cloth. Use a finer cloth and let the mixture rest before straining.
- Rubbery texture. The mixture was overheated or the cheese was drained too long.
- Sour taste. Acid whey and extra acid can make a tangy ricotta. Add a little salt, or mix in cream or milk.
Storage and uses
Fresh whey ricotta is delicate. Keep it in a sealed container in the fridge and use it within a few days. Use it in pasta fillings, on toast with honey, in pancakes or scrambled eggs, or whipped into dips. You can also make the whey stretch further by using it in bread dough, soups and smoothies before it is turned into ricotta.
If you are looking for other simple fresh cheeses, see how to make cheese with 3 ingredients.