Short answer
Yes, a little. The whey you strain off contains some dissolved milk protein, along with water, milk sugar (lactose), minerals and B vitamins. But most of the protein stays in the yogurt, and because so much water leaves, the strained yogurt ends up with more protein in each spoonful than the unstrained version. Strained yogurt has a higher protein concentration, but you get less of it for the same starting amount of milk.
What is in the whey
Whey is the thin, yellowish liquid that separates from yogurt. It is mostly water. It also holds lactose, minerals such as calcium and potassium, some B vitamins, lactic acid, and a small amount of whey protein. If you want to know where this liquid comes from, see why yogurt separates into curds and whey.
Milk has two main protein groups. Casein, the larger share, forms the gel that gives yogurt its body and stays behind in the curd. Whey proteins are the smaller share. When milk is heated for yogurt, a large portion of the whey proteins denature and are caught in the casein network, so they stay with the solids too. Straining mainly removes water, with a smaller loss of the protein that was free in the liquid.
Why strained yogurt has more protein per spoonful
Think of it as concentration. Suppose you start with a quart of yogurt and drain off a cup or two of mostly water. What remains is the same bulk of protein and fat in less volume. A serving by weight or by spoon therefore contains more protein, along with more fat and fewer carbohydrates, since lactose leaves with the whey.
That is why Greek yogurt and similar strained products are known as higher-protein options. Exact figures vary between brands and homemade batches, so check a nutrition label for commercial products. For homemade yogurt, any number you calculate is an estimate.
What you gain and what you lose
You gain
- A thicker, creamier texture
- More protein and fat per spoonful
- Somewhat less lactose per serving, since much of it travels in the whey
- A tangier flavor (see why yogurt tastes too sour)
You lose
- Yield. A batch can shrink by a third to a half or more, depending on how long you strain
- Some protein, calcium, potassium and B vitamins that go out with the whey, unless you use the whey
Should you keep the whey?
If you want to hold on to everything, yes. Whey can go into:
- Smoothies
- Pancake or waffle batter, or bread dough, replacing some water or milk
- Soups and cooking liquids for grains or beans
- A thinner next batch, if you stir some back into the strained yogurt
Store it in the fridge and use it within a few days. If it develops a pink film, an off smell or mold, discard it. See mold, yeast and shelf life.
How much should you strain?
It depends on what you want. Draining for an hour or two gives a modest thickening. Longer draining gives a heavier Greek-style or spreadable result. Timing guidance is in how long it takes to drain yogurt. If you only want the yogurt a bit thicker, stirring in a little milk powder before incubating can raise protein without losing volume, as discussed in whether yogurt gets thicker the longer it ferments.
A note on nutrition claims
Protein content depends on the milk, the culture and how thoroughly you strain. Some websites make strong health claims about whey, particularly in connection with special diets. Those claims are beyond the scope of this article. If you have a medical condition or specific dietary needs, a registered dietitian or doctor is the right person to ask.