What you need
For about 1 quart (roughly 1 liter) of vanilla bean yogurt:
- 4 cups (1 liter) whole milk. Whole milk gives the creamiest result. Pasteurized milk is fine; ultra-pasteurized works for some people, though results vary.
- 1/2 vanilla bean, split lengthwise (or 1 to 2 teaspoons vanilla bean paste)
- 1 to 2 tablespoons sugar or honey (optional)
- 2 tablespoons plain yogurt with live and active cultures, or a yogurt starter packet used according to its directions
- A thermometer, a pot with a lid, and clean jars or a container
Use a fresh, plain yogurt for the starter. One recipe author recommends picking a tub with plenty of time left before its expiry date, since fresher yogurt tends to have livelier cultures.
Method
- Heat the milk with the vanilla. Put the milk in the pot. Scrape the seeds from the vanilla bean into the milk and drop in the pod too. Heat slowly over medium heat, stirring now and then, until the milk reaches about 180°F (82°C). It should be steamy, with small bubbles at the edges. Watch it carefully, because milk can boil over.
- Sweeten (optional). Remove from the heat, fish out the pod and stir in the sugar if you’re using it. Heating the milk to this point helps the yogurt set more firmly.
- Cool. Let the milk cool to about 110 to 115°F (43 to 46°C). It should feel warm but not hot. This takes a while.
- Add the starter. Whisk the starter yogurt with a small amount of the warm milk in a bowl until smooth, then stir it back into the pot. Don’t add the starter to milk that’s too hot, as that can kill the cultures.
- Incubate. Pour into jars, or leave it in the covered pot, and keep it warm and undisturbed. Many batches take roughly 6 to 12 hours, and some are left overnight. Longer incubation means a firmer, tangier yogurt.
- Check. Give the container a gentle nudge. A set yogurt jiggles as a single mass and may have a little clear whey on top.
- Chill. Refrigerate for at least 4 hours. The yogurt gets thicker as it cools.
Vanilla bean, paste or extract?
- Vanilla bean: The fullest, most aromatic flavor, with the tiny black seeds visible in the yogurt. Steeping the pod in the heating milk extracts the most flavor.
- Vanilla bean paste: Almost as good, easier to measure, and gives the flecks too. Add it with the milk.
- Vanilla extract: Convenient. Home yogurt makers report that extract added as the milk cools still lets the yogurt set, but a simpler and safer approach is to stir it in after the yogurt has chilled. See adding vanilla extract to plain Greek yogurt for amounts.
Keeping the yogurt warm
You don’t need a yogurt maker. Some options:
- An oven turned off with only the light on, with the container wrapped in a towel (check the temperature with a thermometer first).
- A slow cooker or pot of warm water, turned off and covered.
- A yogurt maker or a multicooker with a yogurt setting.
- A cooler filled with warm water.
A ceramic or insulated container holds heat well. Aim for a steady temperature of roughly 100 to 115°F (38 to 46°C).
Thicker, Greek-style vanilla yogurt
If you want it thicker, strain the chilled yogurt through a cheesecloth or a clean cotton towel set over a bowl in the fridge. Start with a couple of hours and check, because it can get very thick if you strain it much longer. The liquid that drains off is whey, which can be used in baking or smoothies. Note that straining concentrates the tang, so you may want a bit more sweetener.
Troubleshooting
- Too thin: The starter may have been weak, the milk too hot or cold when you added it, or the temperature may have dropped. Try a longer incubation, a fresh starter, or strain it.
- Too tangy: Shorten the incubation next time.
- Grainy or separated: The milk may have been too hot when the starter went in, or the yogurt was disturbed while setting.
- Vanilla flavor is too light: Use a full bean, add paste after chilling, or stir a bit of extract into each serving.
- It smells or looks wrong: If it smells off, has pink or orange discoloration or mold, discard it.
Storage and saving a starter
Keep the yogurt covered in the fridge and eat it within about a week. You can use a few tablespoons of this batch as a starter for the next one, though with sweetened vanilla yogurt, a plain batch is a more reliable starter. Some people alternate between fresh starter and saved yogurt, since cultures can weaken over many generations.
Serving ideas
Serve with fresh or cooked fruit, granola, nuts, honey or jam. For more topping and sweetener ideas, see our guide to flavoring and sweetening homemade yogurt, or learn why fruit is usually added after fermentation in can you add fruit to milk before making yogurt.