Short answer
If the yogurt is only a little past its printed date, has been kept cold, and shows no signs of spoilage, you can bake with it, use it in marinades, sauces and dressings, blend it into smoothies, or freeze it. If it has mold, colored spots, a rotten or yeasty smell, fizz or a bulging lid, throw it out. Cooking does not rescue yogurt that has already spoiled.
Is it still good? Check first
Dates on yogurt are mostly about quality, such as “best by” or “sell by,” rather than a precise safety cutoff. Many sources say unopened, properly refrigerated yogurt can still be fine for a period past the date, but the numbers they give vary widely, from a few days to a couple of weeks. A cautious approach is to use your senses and judgment rather than count days.
Before using it, check:
- Smell. Tangy and milky is normal. Rancid, rotten, yeasty or beery is not.
- Appearance. No fuzzy mold and no pink, orange, green or gray patches. A little clear liquid on top is just whey (see why yogurt separates).
- Container. The lid or foil should not be puffed or bulging.
- Storage history. It should have stayed refrigerated, around 40°F (4°C) or below. The usual guideline is that perishable food left out more than two hours, or one hour in heat above 90°F (32°C), should be discarded.
- Texture. Slimy, stringy and off-smelling yogurt should go. Mild lumps from stirring or freezing are less worrying.
If you are in any doubt, discard it. This matters most when you are cooking for young children, older adults, pregnant people or anyone with a weakened immune system. For more on spoilage, read mold, yeast and shelf life.
What to do with yogurt that passes the check
Bake with it
Plain yogurt can replace some of the sour cream, buttermilk, milk or oil in many recipes: pancakes, waffles, muffins, quick breads, cakes and biscuits. Its acid reacts with baking soda and keeps the crumb tender. Tangy, older yogurt behaves much like buttermilk.
Use it in marinades
The acid and moisture in plain yogurt are popular in marinades for chicken, lamb and other meats. Add spices, garlic or lemon.
Make sauces, dips and dressings
Stir into tzatziki, ranch-style dips, salad dressings or creamy sauces. A little salt and herbs tone down extra tang. Be careful when adding yogurt to a very hot pan, since it can curdle. Add it off the heat or temper it with a spoonful of the hot liquid first.
Blend into smoothies
Yogurt that is a bit sharp blends easily with banana, berries, honey or mango.
Freeze it
Spoon yogurt into an ice cube tray or onto a lined baking sheet, freeze it and transfer the pieces to a freezer bag. Frozen yogurt can keep for a couple of months in many sources, though the texture usually turns grainy when it thaws, so use it in smoothies or baking rather than eating it plain.
Turn it into strained yogurt or labneh-style cheese
Draining thicker yogurt through cloth gives a spreadable, cream-cheese-like result. The longer you drain, the thicker it gets. See how long it takes to drain yogurt. Only do this with yogurt that is still good to eat.
What about very sour homemade yogurt?
A homemade batch that ended up much too tart, but is clean-smelling and has no mold, is usually fine for cooking and baking. The extra acid is useful in pancakes, flatbreads and marinades. If it tastes bitter or harsh, see why homemade yogurt tastes bitter and why yogurt tastes too sour.
When to throw it out
Discard yogurt that:
- Has any mold or colored spots (see pink, orange or gray spots in yogurt)
- Smells rotten, rancid or yeasty
- Is fizzy, bubbling or in a bulging container
- Was left out for hours
- Has been open for a long time and you cannot be sure of its history
Do not scrape off the top and keep the rest. Mold in soft foods can spread beyond what you can see.
Other ideas
Some people add small amounts of old but unspoiled yogurt to compost, or use it in homemade skin or hair treatments. Evidence for the skin uses is thin, so test a small patch if you try it, and do not use anything that smells off. Do not feed spoiled yogurt to pets.
Use it up sooner next time
- Buy smaller tubs, or make smaller homemade batches.
- Keep yogurt on a main shelf, not the fridge door.
- Use a clean spoon each time.
- Freeze portions before they get old.