Flavored and Frozen Yogurt

Can you add vanilla extract to plain Greek yogurt?

Yes, you can add vanilla extract to plain Greek yogurt. Here's how much to use per cup, what sweeteners pair well, and how to avoid a sharp, harsh flavor.

On this page
  1. Yes, and here’s how much to use
  2. Does vanilla extract sweeten yogurt?
  3. Extract, paste, bean or imitation?
  4. Step by step
  5. Fixing common problems
  6. Ideas to add
  7. Is vanilla Greek yogurt healthy? Can vanilla yogurt replace plain?
  8. Adding vanilla before the yogurt is made

Yes, and here’s how much to use

Yes, you can stir vanilla extract into plain Greek yogurt, and it’s one of the quickest ways to turn it into a vanilla yogurt. A good starting point is:

  • 1 cup (about 240 g) plain Greek yogurt
  • 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract (up to 1 teaspoon if you like a stronger flavor)
  • 1 to 2 teaspoons honey, maple syrup or sugar, to taste (some people use up to a tablespoon)

Stir until smooth, taste, and adjust. It’s easier to add more than to take it back.

Does vanilla extract sweeten yogurt?

Not on its own. Vanilla has no real sugar in it, but it has a warm, rounded aroma that makes yogurt taste sweeter and less sharp. So a little sweetener goes a long way, and you may find you need less than you thought. If you don’t want to add sugar at all, vanilla plus fruit, cinnamon or a few chopped nuts can work.

Extract, paste, bean or imitation?

  • Pure vanilla extract: Easy to find and dissolves smoothly. It contains alcohol, though the amount in a half teaspoon of extract spread through a cup of yogurt is small. Alcohol-free vanilla is available if you prefer it.
  • Vanilla bean paste: Thicker than extract, with visible flecks and a deeper flavor. Use roughly the same amount as extract.
  • Whole vanilla bean: The strongest flavor. Split the pod, scrape out the seeds and stir them in. This is best if you’re making a larger batch. See how to make vanilla bean yogurt at home.
  • Imitation vanilla: Cheaper and works in a pinch, but can taste harsher or more artificial, so start with less.

Step by step

  1. Spoon the yogurt into a bowl.
  2. Add the vanilla and sweetener.
  3. Stir or whisk until fully blended with no streaks.
  4. Taste and adjust.
  5. For the best flavor, let it sit in the fridge for 15 to 30 minutes.

Fixing common problems

  • Too sharp or “boozy”: You’ve probably used too much extract. Stir in more yogurt, or switch to paste or alcohol-free vanilla next time.
  • Still too tangy: Add a little more sweetener, or stir in mashed banana or a spoonful of jam.
  • Gritty: If you used granulated sugar, it may not have dissolved. Use powdered sugar, honey or maple syrup instead.
  • Runny: Whisking vigorously thins yogurt. Fold gently and use a thicker, strained yogurt.

Ideas to add

Once you have vanilla yogurt, you can build on it with cinnamon, a pinch of cardamom, fresh or cooked fruit, nuts, seeds, granola or a little nut butter. For more combinations and sweetener options, see our guide to flavoring and sweetening homemade yogurt.

Is vanilla Greek yogurt healthy? Can vanilla yogurt replace plain?

Homemade vanilla yogurt made this way gives you control over the sugar, which is usually its biggest nutritional difference from plain yogurt. Store-bought vanilla Greek yogurt is typically sweetened, so check the label for added sugar. If a recipe calls for plain yogurt, vanilla yogurt will work in some sweet dishes but will change the flavor and sweetness, and it’s usually a poor swap in savory recipes. If you need to match a recipe, it’s safer to start with plain and add your own vanilla.

Adding vanilla before the yogurt is made

If you’re making your own yogurt rather than flavoring a finished one, there are options for putting the vanilla in earlier. A vanilla bean steeped in the milk as it heats is a reliable method. Extract and a small amount of sugar are sometimes stirred into the warm milk too, but the simplest approach for consistent results is to add them after the yogurt has set. Learn more in our article on adding fruit and flavorings to milk before making yogurt.

The complete guide to flavored and frozen yogurt

How to Flavor and Sweeten Homemade Yogurt
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →