Short answer
Not technically. Froyo (frozen yogurt) and ice cream are both frozen dairy desserts, and they look similar, but they’re made from different bases. Ice cream is built on cream and milk and, in the United States, has to meet a minimum milkfat level to be sold as ice cream. Frozen yogurt is made with cultured milk or yogurt and usually has less fat. In everyday conversation, plenty of people lump them together, and that’s fine. It only matters when you’re reading labels or comparing nutrition.
The milkfat rule
In the United States, a product generally has to contain at least 10% milkfat to be labeled ice cream. Frozen yogurt is usually lower in fat than that, and it isn’t covered by the same standard, so manufacturers have more freedom in what goes into it, including how much real yogurt. Rules differ in other countries, so check local labeling if you’re outside the US.
Ingredients: cultured milk vs cream
- Ice cream: cream, milk, sugar, and often egg yolks, plus flavorings. There’s no fermentation step.
- Frozen yogurt: milk that has been cultured with yogurt bacteria (or yogurt added to a mix), plus sugar, flavorings and often stabilizers.
That culturing step is what gives froyo its tang. Our explainer on what frozen yogurt is goes into more detail on how it’s made.
Fat, sugar and calories
Frozen yogurt generally has less fat and fewer calories than ice cream. But sugar is a different story. Because the yogurt base is tangy, many commercial frozen yogurts add plenty of sugar to balance it, and the sugar content can be close to ice cream’s, or even higher. Toppings like candy, cookie pieces and syrups can add a lot more. Nutrition varies widely by brand and serving size, so compare labels rather than assuming froyo is the lighter choice on every measure.
Live cultures are another point of difference. Some frozen yogurts contain live cultures and some don’t, so froyo isn’t automatically a probiotic food.
Taste and texture
Ice cream is typically richer, creamier and fluffier, thanks to the cream and the air churned into it. Froyo tends to feel lighter and a bit tangier. Some people find it less rich, and others prefer that. Homemade frozen yogurt can also freeze harder than shop-made soft-serve unless you take steps to keep it smooth; see our no-churn homemade frozen yogurt guide.
So which should you choose?
It comes down to what you want. If you’re after a lighter, tangier dessert with less fat, froyo fits. If you want a rich, creamy treat, ice cream is hard to beat. If you’re watching sugar in particular, look at the label for both rather than assuming one is better. Either one can fit into a balanced diet in moderation.
Making froyo at home
At home you decide how sweet it is and what goes in it. Thick yogurt, a sweetener and fruit are enough to make a decent version without a machine, and you can adjust the tang and sugar as you like. You can also start from a flavored batch of your own yogurt, using ideas from our guide to flavoring and sweetening homemade yogurt.