What makes Turkish yogurt Turkish?
The word yogurt itself comes from Turkish (yoğurt), and yogurt is one of the foundations of Turkish cooking. A traditional Turkish home method is simple and does not need a machine:
- the milk is simmered for a while rather than just warmed,
- it is cooled to a hand-tolerable warmth (the classic “finger test”),
- a spoonful of the previous batch is stirred in, and
- the pot is wrapped in towels or a blanket to hold the heat while it sets.
The result is a smooth, creamy, mildly tart, unstrained yogurt, often with a thin skin of cream on top. If strained, it becomes süzme yoğurt. For how this compares with other warm-set styles, see our overview of yogurt styles around the world.
Ingredients and equipment
- 2 liters (about 2 quarts) whole milk. Full-fat milk gives the creamiest, thickest result.
- 2 to 4 tablespoons plain yogurt with live cultures, at room temperature, as a starter. Use fresh, unflavored yogurt. After your first batch, you can use your own yogurt.
- A heavy-bottomed pot with a lid, a thermometer (recommended), a whisk, a towel or blanket, and clean containers if you want to portion it.
Method
- Simmer the milk. Bring the milk to a boil in a heavy pot, then lower the heat and simmer gently for about 15 to 20 minutes, stirring now and then so it does not scorch. This reduces the milk a little and helps give a thicker yogurt. Keep an eye on it, since milk can boil over quickly.
- Cool to incubation temperature. Let the milk cool to about 43°C (110°F), within a range of roughly 40–45°C. Without a thermometer, use the traditional test: a clean finger should be able to stay in the milk for about 4 to 5 seconds without it feeling too hot. If a skin has formed, you can lift it off or stir it in.
- Temper the starter. Whisk the starter with a few tablespoons to half a cup of the warm milk until smooth, then stir it back into the pot. This prevents lumps.
- Wrap and incubate. Cover the pot, then wrap it in a towel and blanket. Leave it somewhere warm and draft-free, without moving it, for about 3 to 6 hours. Warm weather needs less time, cool weather more.
- Chill. Once it looks set, refrigerate it, ideally overnight and without stirring, so it firms up completely.
Store it covered in the refrigerator and eat it within several days to about a week. Save a few tablespoons as a starter for the next batch, ideally within a few days.
Tips for a thicker yogurt
- Use whole milk. Low-fat milk gives a thinner set.
- Simmer longer, within reason, to concentrate the milk.
- Do not disturb the pot while it sets.
- Chill it overnight before judging the texture.
- For a very thick result, strain it. See how to make Greek-style yogurt for the straining method, or Persian-style yogurt for a closely related warm-set approach.
Troubleshooting
- Runny: the milk was too hot or too cool when the starter went in, the pot was moved, or the starter was weak. Try fresh starter and check the temperature.
- Grainy or lots of whey: it set at too high a temperature or for too long.
- Too sour: shorten the time or use less starter.
- Did not set at all: the starter may have been old, or the milk too hot. A new batch of fresh starter usually works.
- Off smell, pink or fuzzy patches: discard it.
How Turkish cooks use it
- Cacık: yogurt thinned a little with cucumber, garlic, mint or dill.
- Haydari: a thick strained-yogurt dip with garlic and herbs.
- Ayran: yogurt whisked with cold water and a pinch of salt.
- Alongside meals: with pasta, dumplings (like manti), stuffed vegetables or grilled meats.
- Süzme yoğurt: strained until thick and eaten with honey or in dips.
To see how dahi differs when it is set at kitchen temperature, read curd, dahi and Greek yogurt.