Short answer
There is no single, agreed date. Yogurt appeared in the United States in small amounts in the first decade of the 20th century, as a health food and home-culturing curiosity. Regular commercial sales by immigrant-run dairies followed in the 1920s and 1930s (for example, Colombo and Sons in Massachusetts, starting in 1929). The Dannon brand began producing in New York in the early 1940s, and yogurt became a mainstream supermarket item in the decades after that.
Which of these counts as “first” depends on whether you mean any sale at all, the first commercial dairy, or the first widely available brand.
A short timeline
- Early 1900s. After Élie Metchnikoff’s writing on yogurt and longevity (his book The Prolongation of Life appeared in English in 1908), American interest grew. Yogurt was promoted as a health food, available in forms such as tablets and cultures for home use. John Harvey Kellogg also promoted it at the Battle Creek Sanitarium as part of his health regimen.
- 1929. Armenian immigrants Sarkis and Rose Colombosian started Colombo and Sons Creamery in Andover, Massachusetts. According to historical accounts, early deliveries around New England carried the Armenian word madzoon (also written matzoon), later replaced with the more familiar “yogurt.”
- Early 1940s. Daniel Carasso, whose family business had grown into Danone in Europe, took refuge in New York in 1941 and launched Dannon Milk Products in 1942 after acquiring a small yogurt maker there. Some sources give 1941 for the first US factory, which reflects this overlap.
- 1950s and 1960s. Yogurt was presented as a health food by scientists and nutrition writers, but plain yogurt was often too sour for many American tastes.
- 1966. Colombo introduced a sweetened “fruit on the bottom” yogurt, which helped broaden its appeal.
- Late 20th century. Yogurt became a common item in American refrigerators. Colombo was sold to General Mills in 1993 and later discontinued.
- Mid-2000s onward. Strained, “Greek-style” yogurt took off, helped by brands such as Chobani. See who invented Greek yogurt.
Why there is no single date
Early yogurt in the US was often made and sold locally by immigrant families from the Eastern Mediterranean, Caucasus and Balkans, who brought their own culturing traditions. Records of small, local sales are patchy, and “first” is therefore hard to prove. What is well documented is the arrival of the idea (early 1900s), the first long-lived commercial dairies (Colombo in 1929), and the growth of the major brands (Dannon in the 1940s).
Make it the old-fashioned way
Before commercial yogurt was everywhere, American households cultured it from a spoonful of the previous batch, much like the room-temperature Caucasian cultures that Armenian dairies were selling. If you want to try that tradition, see how to make matsoni, or compare it with the warm-incubated Bulgarian-style approach. For the bigger history, see yogurt styles around the world.